Open navigation
Search

Unfair terms in online contracts

Cass. ord. n. 20945/2026

18 Nov 2026 Italy 3 min read

1. The ruling

In Order No. 20945 of 20 June 2026, the Italian Supreme Court (Corte di Cassazione) considered a B2B electricity supply agreement entered into online via the supplier’s website. The supplier’s standard terms included an exclusive jurisdiction clause, which the supplier argued the customer had accepted by ticking the relevant box twice (a so-called “double flag”).

Under Article 1341(2) of the Italian Civil Code, unfair terms (“clausole vessatorie”) in standard form contracts are only effective if specifically approved in writing – a rule the Court confirmed also applies to online contracts. In the Court’s view, a tick-box does not meet this requirement on its own: the clause must instead be approved with an electronic signature, even a simple one such as an OTP code sent by text or e-mail, through a dedicated step in the online contracting process. As this had not happened, the clause was held to be ineffective (i.e. not binding on the customer).

2. Why it matters

The prevailing line of Italian case law has so far held that ticking a checkbox (a so-called “flag”) is sufficient to constitute the specific written approval of unfair terms required by Article 1341(2) of the Italian Civil Code. This has allowed businesses to obtain that approval as part of the standard online checkout process, without any additional steps. The Court’s interpretation complicates matters: should it become settled case law, it could have a significant impact on e-commerce in Italy, which already faces a requirement largely unknown in other jurisdictions – the separate, additional signature of unfair terms.

As a result, the clauses most commonly found in online standard terms and conditions – such as jurisdiction, limitation of liability, withdrawal and unilateral amendment clauses – could be challenged where they have been approved merely by ticking a box.

3. Practical steps

As a precaution, we recommend that businesses contracting online with other businesses:

  • review how unfair terms in their general terms and conditions are currently accepted during the online sign-up process;
  • consider adding a dedicated step in which customers approve those terms with a simple electronic signature (e.g. an OTP code), either alongside or instead of tick-boxes.
  • keep records of how the online sign-up process appeared when the contract was concluded (e.g. screenshots, system logs and OTP codes), since in the event of a dispute the business bears the burden of proving how the clause was approved.
Back to top Back to top
Warning: Fraudulent emails and messages
Opens in new window