The Digital Fairness Act: How Brussels plans to reshape EU digital consumer law
Please confirm you are human to start the audio.
After years of consultation, the European Commission presented the first draft of the Digital Fairness Act ("DFA") on 11 November 2026. The proposal amounts to nothing less than a fundamental reorganisation of consumer protection law in the digital sphere. In particular, it takes the shift towards preventive, "by design" regulation, initiated by the Digital Services Act and further advanced by the draft EU KIDS Act, further than almost any previous regulatory initiative.
Digital Fairness Act: the key changes in the EU draft
The real surprise of the draft lies less in individual obligations and prohibitions than in its architecture: rather than merely supplementing the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (UCPD), the DFA converts the UCPD in its entirety into a directly applicable regulation. Alongside this structural change to unfair commercial practices law, the DFA contains a new blacklist of prohibited dark patterns, i.e. manipulative website and app designs such as false scarcity and popularity claims or pre-ticked add-on products. The Commission may amend this blacklist by delegated act.
Consistent with the “by design” approach that also underlies the KIDS Act, the draft also contains numerous, highly specific rules of conduct for commercial practices and for typical website and app designs. They mainly concern issues that the Commission's Digital Fairness Fitness Check identified as problematic: addictive design, virtual currencies, influencer marketing and personalised advertising. In anticipation of the structural changes coming in the digital space, the draft also regulates contracts concluded by AI agents: consumers must specify how far an agent may act on their behalf, and sponsored recommendations can never lead to a purchase fully automatically.
Numerous provisions also focus on protecting minors. Paid loot boxes and pay-to-win mechanisms may not be offered to minors where a product is directed at minors or the trader is aware with reasonable certainty that minors use it. Stricter rules for minors also apply to influencer marketing, profiling-based advertising and personalised pricing. The DFA thus extends the regulation of commercial design to protect minors, already laid down in the KIDS Act, beyond the rules for social networks, video-sharing platforms and AI companions.
Finally, the draft strengthens the enforcement of unfair commercial practices and consumer law. In the case of widespread infringements with a Union dimension, the Commission will be able to conduct its own investigations and impose fines of up to 6% of worldwide annual turnover. With regard to the protection of minors from in-game monetisation and to addictive design, national authorities may not take decisions that run counter to decisions of the Commission.
The following overview summarises the key provisions of the DFA draft.
The new unfair commercial practices law: conversion of the UCPD into a regulation
The Fitness Check had already indicated that the DFA would cover numerous design practices that are currently regulated primarily through unfair commercial practices law. Until the very end, however, it remained open whether the DFA would amend the existing directives only selectively or, like the DSA, create its own rules on particularly problematic practices. That it instead takes over the entire body of unfair commercial practices law is remarkable, but consistent, since it simultaneously consolidates the new digital rules, the green claims and obsolescence prohibitions of the Empowering Consumers Directive (EmpCo) and parts of the ePrivacy Directive (now Article 28 DFA) in a single legal act. This serves the DFA's stated aim of reducing fragmentation and avoiding a situation in which the same subject matter is governed by different laws for different providers and situations.
In structural terms, the DFA draft adopts the basic provisions of the UCPD, such as the prohibition of misleading or aggressive practices, almost unchanged. It makes substantive changes in only three areas:
- The "transactional decision" will in future expressly include the decision to continue using a product or to exercise a contractual right (Article 3(6)), such as continuing to scroll in an app. General unfair commercial practices law will thus, for the first time, also apply to pure retention mechanisms.
- Consumers will in future be considered vulnerable not only because of age, disability or credulity, but also because of any specific misfortune or circumstance of such gravity as to impair their judgment (Article 5(3)). The recitals cite financial distress as an example (Recital 27).
- Finally, any breach of the obligations in the new Chapter III on "digital fairness" (Articles 10 to 29) automatically constitutes an unfair commercial practice (Article 5(4)(c)).
This considerably broadens the potential scope of unfair commercial practices law. The expansion goes hand in hand with the Commission's effort to address certain undesirable practices in a targeted manner and in the interest of consumers.
The most far-reaching change concerns the blacklist of misleading practices. Strikethrough prices on websites and in apps are generally permitted today and widely used. Under Annex I, point 11, a price comparison using a strikethrough price, a percentage or an absolute saving will in future always be unfair if the reference price is not a current price charged for the product by a clearly identified competitor on the market. The recitals expressly mention the manufacturer's recommended retail price as an impermissible reference price, while still allowing a comparison between a second-hand or refurbished product and the same product new. Advertising along the lines of "RRP €199, now only €129" would thus be prohibited.
Also new is the prohibition of drip pricing, i.e. prices that do not already include all foreseeable and unavoidable costs when the price is first indicated. This does not apply to costs that can only be determined during the ordering process, such as delivery charges that depend on the address, order value or delivery method (Recital 106).
Finally, the Commission has addressed the much-criticised practices in ticket sales. Where ticket prices may rise dynamically, traders will in future have to state how many tickets in the relevant ticket category are available at the advertised price and the maximum price that may apply (Article 18(1)). In virtual queues, traders must display the current price from the moment of entry, updated in real time, together with whether the price may vary and the maximum price (Article 19). Anyone reselling tickets must also state the original total price charged by the event organiser and, where applicable, the category, row and seat (Article 18(2)). The draft does not contain a ban on dynamic ticket pricing, as consumer associations had called for.
Dark patterns: new prohibitions on manipulative website and app design
The Commission's Fitness Check had already identified dark patterns as a key problem for consumers in the EU. Dark patterns are website and app design features that steer users towards decisions they would not otherwise make. Against this background, the DFA contains specific rules on them.
The Commission therefore supplements unfair commercial practices law with a standalone prohibition of dark patterns in Article 10(1). Under this provision, traders may not design, organise or operate their online interfaces in a manner that is likely to deceive or manipulate consumers or otherwise materially distort their economic behaviour. Unlike the general clauses of unfair commercial practices law, this does not require a breach of professional diligence. The prohibition is complemented by ten new items on the blacklist (Annex I, Part III, points 53 to 62), such as pre-ticked add-on products, presenting a refusal as the "wrong choice", false statements about the availability or popularity of a product, and refusal processes that are disproportionately more burdensome than necessary. The Commission may add to the list by delegated act (Article 10(3)).
Since dark patterns have so far been addressed mainly through unfair commercial practices law, data protection law and Article 25 DSA, the draft also expressly clarifies the relationship with the DSA: the dark pattern prohibition in Article 25 DSA does not apply to dark patterns that fall under the DFA as B2C commercial practices (Recital 51). To that extent, the DFA becomes the relevant standard for platforms.
Addictive design: Digital Fairness Act plans new opt-out rights
Addictive design refers to designs intended to keep users engaged with a service for as long and as often as possible. These include well-known techniques such as infinite scroll, video autoplay or engagement rewards, for example rewards for playing an online game every day.
The DFA does not prohibit such designs but makes their permissibility subject to an opt-out model. It requires every trader whose digital products are designed, organised or operated in a manner that is intended, or can reasonably be foreseen, to encourage compulsive or excessive use to provide easily accessible and effective tools. With these tools, users must be able to switch off autoplay and infinite feeds, notifications unrelated to the user's own activity, streaks and penalties for inactivity, as well as features that simulate interpersonal relationships, for example in AI companions, individually or all at once (Article 17(1)). To capture new forms of addictive design, the Commission may also extend the list by delegated act (Article 17(2)).
For traders subject to the corresponding provisions of the KIDS Act, Article 17 DFA does not apply to practices concerning minors: for them, the stricter regime of the KIDS Act applies, which contains far-reaching requirements and prohibitions on addictive design. Educational and scientific services within the meaning of the KIDS Act are also entirely exempt.
In practice, a key question will be when Article 17 applies: the draft does not clearly define what makes a product designed for excessive use. For numerous services, such as online games with daily login rewards or season passes, this will be one of the central questions of DFA compliance.
Virtual currencies, loot boxes and pay-to-win: transparency for all, prohibitions for minors
The Fitness Check had already identified virtual currencies and the related debates on transparency and fairness as a core issue for the DFA. The core problem it identified is that, in many games, items cannot be purchased directly with real money but only with an in-game currency such as gold or coins. When that currency is sold only in fixed bundles that do not match in-game prices, players can quickly lose track of what an item actually costs. In addition to the Fitness Check, the network of national consumer protection authorities (CPC) published its Key Principles on in-game virtual currencies as early as March 2025. These, however, were merely an interpretation of existing law rather than new regulation.
Given these long-running debates, it is no surprise that the DFA contains new rules in this area:
- Anyone offering paid-for virtual currencies must in future state the monetary value (or estimated monetary value) of the virtual items or other products that can be bought with them, in the currency in which the consumer acquired the virtual currency (Article 14(1)). Consumers should therefore be able to see how much they are actually spending.
- Where the product is directed at minors or the trader is aware with reasonable certainty that minors use it, paid-for virtual currencies must be disabled by default for minors and may only be activated with the approval of a parent or guardian (Article 14(2)).
Loot boxes have always been even more controversial than virtual currencies because of their proximity to gambling. They are digital “mystery boxes” found mostly in video games. Players pay for such a box with real money or a purchased in-game currency but do not know in advance which virtual item they will receive. This random mechanism leads some players to spend enormous sums to obtain the item they want.
Owing to the lack of harmonisation of gambling law and the wide range of designs, the regulation of loot boxes within the EU has so far been highly fragmented: Belgium, for example, has classified paid loot boxes as prohibited gambling since 2018, whereas in Germany loot boxes do not constitute gambling unless the publisher operates a secondary market, so they are only taken into account by the German age rating body USK.
The DFA now introduces a uniform rule for paid loot boxes (referred to in the draft as "paid-for variable reward systems"): consumers must always be informed about the types of products or virtual items available and the probability of obtaining them (Article 15(1)). In addition, all consumers must be given easily accessible and effective tools to disable paid loot boxes (Article 15(2)). Here, too, the DFA is strict towards minors: under the same conditions as for virtual currencies, paid loot boxes may not be offered to them at all (Article 15(3)).
In both cases, the decisive questions are when a product is directed at minors and when the trader is aware with reasonable certainty that minors use it. Based on Recital 62, virtually every game with an age rating (e.g. PEGI) indicating suitability for under-18s is likely to be directed at minors. A trader is deemed to have such awareness, for example, where a customer account allows it to establish that the account belongs to a minor. The trader is not required to collect additional personal data for this purpose (Recital 32).
Under Article 16 DFA, pay-to-progress and pay-to-win mechanisms are subject to the same prohibition for minors, under the same conditions. Such mechanisms are typically found in online games, where they enable or promise in-game progress or advantages in exchange for payment. The practical impact of prohibiting pay-to-progress and pay-to-win mechanisms for minors is considerable, as it covers all purchases that are necessary for progress or success, or are merely presented as necessary. The recitals (Recital 65) give as examples artificial difficulty barriers, progression speeds that render the unpaid path illusory, and competitive structures in which outcomes are effectively determined by expenditure. By contrast, purely cosmetic items such as skins, which only change the appearance of a character, are unlikely to be covered. For virtual items that can be used in the game, however, it will have to be assessed case by case whether the practical effects of owning them within the game are equivalent to those of the examples given in the recitals.
Influencer marketing: DFA plans new labelling obligations and more responsibility for businesses
Under current law, advertising must already be recognisable as such. For influencers, however, this obligation has so far followed only from the general rules of unfair commercial practices law and media regulation. These regimes are not tailored to videos, posts and livestreams and are also applied differently across Member States. The DFA now addresses the issue expressly for the first time. Influencer marketing is defined as a commercial practice whereby traders use their popularity among their audience to promote products in exchange for payment. To prevent circumvention, the recitals expressly state that gifts and invitations also count as payment.
Commercial communication must in future be clearly and expressly labelled as "advertisement" or "commercial collaboration" in every single post (Article 11). For advertising shown on platforms, the labelling function that platforms are required to provide under the DSA must also be used.
Beyond this, the DFA also contains several clear prohibitions. These cover direct exhortations to minors to buy, concealing the commercial purpose, particularly where minors themselves appear, and creating the false impression that a product is suitable for children.
Finally, the DFA introduces a new regulatory approach by extending responsibility to the brands and advertisers concerned. Anyone who engages influencers must ensure, by contract or, where there is no contract, by other appropriate means, that they comply with these obligations. According to the recitals, contractual provisions cannot be used to exclude the advertiser's own liability. For businesses, this means that long-term influencer contracts and the associated approval processes in particular should be reviewed now, in view of the DFA's future entry into force.
Personalised offers and prices: new limits under the DFA
Many online retailers and apps tailor offers, discounts and even prices to individual users based on the data they hold about them. In the digital space, prices are therefore by no means the same for all users. Legislators have so far been very cautious in this area. Since 2022, traders have merely had to indicate when a price has been personalised on the basis of automated decision-making. They have not, however, had to explain how exactly the price is calculated.
The DFA draws clear limits here: personalised prices based on profiling are prohibited where they are reasonably likely to cause harm and the trader is aware with reasonable certainty that the consumer is a minor or is vulnerable due to age, credulity, disability or any specific misfortune or circumstance of such gravity as to impair their judgment (Article 13). According to the recitals, student and senior rebates as well as pricing based on evidence-based insurance risk remain permitted.
In practice, the threshold of "reasonable certainty" is decisive. Businesses are not required to collect additional data to identify minors or vulnerable consumers. However, anyone who knows from a customer account that they are dealing with a minor cannot claim ignorance. The draft does not contain a general ban on personalised pricing.
The DFA also tackles profiling-based advertising. Since 2024, the DSA has prohibited online platforms from presenting profiling-based advertising to minors as well as advertising based on sensitive data such as health or religion. The DFA extends these prohibitions to all other traders, while platforms remain subject to the DSA.
AI agents: new rules for automated contracting
AI agents that search for, compare and buy products on behalf of consumers pose a fundamental challenge for consumer law, which assumes that a human reads information before making a decision. The DFA therefore expressly regulates automated contracting for the first time (Articles 26 and 27), on a technology-neutral basis for any "automated system" that concludes contracts on behalf of consumers. Any trader providing consumers with such an agent must ensure that, on first use, the consumer expressly chooses whether they wish to confirm every proposed contract, only certain contracts based on criteria they set themselves, such as a maximum price and a time limit, or none at all. The trader must confirm this choice to the consumer on a durable medium, and the consumer can change it at any time.
The rule on conflicts of interest is particularly relevant in practice. If the provider receives payment for proposing a contract or has any other conflict of interest, for example because the agent favours a particular trader's products, this must be disclosed. The contract then always requires the consumer's confirmation, irrespective of which option the consumer has chosen. Sponsored recommendations can therefore never lead to a purchase without the consumer's confirmation. In addition, the agent must transmit the necessary contact details to the trader, and the trader must confirm the conclusion of the contract. Conversely, traders may not require consumers to use agents to access their online interfaces or to conclude transactions (Article 26(9)). Where the contract is concluded exclusively by automated systems on both sides, machine-readable information suffices, and some of the formal requirements of the Consumer Rights Directive no longer apply (Article 27).
The draft leaves two points open: it does not give consumers a right to prevent traders from locking out agents, and it does not regulate who is liable if an agent concludes an unwanted contract. These questions remain governed by Member States' contract laws.
Subscription traps: new rules on free trials, cancellation and contract renewals
The Fitness Check identified how online service subscriptions are sold and structured as a key concern. The DFA addresses this as follows:
Where a free trial would otherwise convert automatically into a paid subscription, the consumer is only bound if they were reminded before the trial ends and have expressly agreed to continue the subscription on a paid basis (Article 20). Opt-out thus becomes opt-in.
For automatic renewals of contracts with a term of six months or longer, the trader must remind the consumer of the upcoming renewal and of their right to terminate no earlier than one month and no later than 14 days beforehand (Article 21). If no reminder is sent, the consumer may terminate at any time free of charge until the reminder is sent, without having to pay for the period since the renewal. After a renewal for an indefinite period, the consumer may terminate at any time with no more than one month's notice. For short-term subscriptions, a reminder must be sent at least one week before the renewal by which the total term reaches six months or the contract is renewed for the tenth time, whichever occurs first (Article 22).
Finally, the DFA provides for an EU-wide "online contract termination function" (a cancellation button) labelled "terminate the contract here" or an equivalent unambiguous wording, which every trader that allows contracts to be concluded online must provide. It must also be available for contracts concluded offline (Article 23(1)). After the function has been used, the trader must acknowledge receipt of the termination without undue delay and at the latest within one week, stating when it takes effect (Article 23(5)). For countries such as Germany or France, which have already introduced their own rules, this means that the design of their cancellation buttons will have to be aligned with the EU requirements.
DFA enforcement: the Commission as a European consumer authority
For many of the issues addressed by the DFA draft, rules and laws already exist today. However, they are rarely enforced, and enforcement tends to focus on large providers and constellations where the case is clear. In its 2024 report on the application of the CPC Regulation, the Commission also criticised lengthy proceedings and unevenly resourced authorities.
Against this background, it is only consistent that the DFA addresses not only substantive law but also enforcement.
The DFA draft provides that, in the case of widespread infringements with a Union dimension, the Commission will in future be able to investigate and take action itself (Article 30(4)). This includes fines of up to 6% of worldwide annual turnover (Article 35(6)). The details are set out in the revision of the CPC Regulation proposed in parallel. The Commission would thus no longer merely coordinate national authorities but would itself act as a consumer protection authority in large cross-border cases, similar to its role under the DSA for very large platforms. For the rules protecting minors in relation to virtual currencies, loot boxes and pay-to-win mechanisms, as well as for addictive design, the draft also secures a uniform approach: national authorities may not take decisions that run counter to decisions already adopted by the Commission (Article 30(8)). Where the Commission is in any event competent under the DSA or the AI Act, its powers also extend to these obligations (Article 30(7)).
Also new is a far-reaching disclosure obligation for commercial practices in the online environment (Article 34). Where a claimant has presented facts and evidence sufficient to support the likelihood of an infringement, or an authority has a reasonable suspicion, courts and authorities may require the trader to disclose evidence of how the practice is designed and operated and how it affects consumer behaviour. A failure to disclose may be taken into account in establishing unfairness and may be subject to penalties. A/B tests, engagement metrics and personalisation logic thus become relevant evidence.
Finally, the rule in Article 5(4)(c) DFA mentioned above is particularly relevant: any breach of the new digital obligations in Chapter III (Articles 10 to 29) also constitutes an unfair commercial practice. Since Member States must continue to make remedies available to persons and organisations with a legitimate interest, including competitors (Article 30(1)), competitors and associations will be able to pursue such breaches as before under national unfair competition law, for example by way of warning letters and injunction proceedings. A missing cancellation button, failure to disclose loot box probabilities or an autoplay function that cannot be switched off may therefore give rise to claims by competitors. Private enforcement, in particular, is likely to have a wider impact much sooner than lengthy Commission proceedings.
Digital Fairness Act: next steps and implications for businesses
With the Commission's proposal, the legislative procedure with Parliament and Council now begins. It remains to be seen which provisions will survive unchanged in the final text. In any case, the DFA would only apply twelve months after its entry into force (Article 40), so, in our assessment, it is unlikely to apply before 2028.
Points of contention are already emerging: according to media reports, the German Federal Government does not consider it sufficiently established that the UCPD needs to be converted into a regulation and would prefer to amend the existing directives rather than create a new horizontal act. The Commission's new powers will also be contested, as will the possibility of extending the blacklist by delegated act and its relationship with the DSA, the AI Act and the KIDS Act. Alongside the DFA, the Commission has proposed a directive amending the Consumer Rights Directive and the ePrivacy Directive to simplify consumer protection rules, which complements the picture in some respects.
Regardless of how much of the draft survives the legislative process, the direction is already clear. Unfair commercial practices law is not only being Europeanised but is also becoming considerably more specific and, through the Commission's new powers, easier to enforce. Broad general provisions, whose scope has so far had to be determined case by case by the courts, are increasingly being supplemented by detailed requirements for the design of digital products, meaning that compliance will in future have to start at the product development stage. For the German UWG (as for all other Member States' unfair competition laws), this marks a turning point: in consumer matters, the substantive rules will in future come directly from Brussels, while private enforcement by way of warning letters and injunction proceedings would continue to be governed by German law.
Businesses should therefore not wait for the procedure to be concluded before reviewing their digital offerings. Since adjustments to user interfaces and business models typically require considerable lead time, businesses should now assess their products and processes against the draft's key obligations.
The draft thus provides plenty of material for discussion and, as so often, the devil is in the detail. Over the coming weeks, we will therefore examine the individual areas of regulation in separate articles in this series.