Marketing preventive healthcare: Making strong claims without risking a formal warning
Please confirm you are human to start the audio.
Authors
Prevention thrives on promises. A longer life, more energy, healthier ageing – these messages have great marketing potential. However, something that is compelling from a marketing perspective can entail legal risks when advertising preventive healthcare products. Which health-related advertising messages are permitted depends largely on the regulatory classification of the product or service. Different requirements apply to medical devices, medicinal products and nutritional supplements.
Preventive healthcare advertising: What regulations apply?
Advertisers in the preventive healthcare market operate in the space between many overlapping legal frameworks – each with its own set of rules.
The German Unfair Competition Act (UWG) is designed to combat unfair commercial practices across all sectors. One particularly relevant provision to the preventive healthcare market is the prohibition on misleading advertising, meaning claims that give consumers a false impression of the product's effects, composition or scientific evidence. A company that claims for example that its product prolongs life or prevents certain medical conditions without being able to substantiate this may be acting in breach of competition law. Competitors may issue the company a formal warning and the courts may order it to cease and desist from such practices.
Health advertising under the German Act on Advertising in the Field of Health
Where medicinal products, medical devices or other remedies, goods, procedures or treatments relating to medical conditions are concerned, the German Act on Advertising in the Field of Health (HWG) also applies. Because people's health is a particularly valuable asset that warrants protection, the HWG imposes strict requirements on advertising messages: Health claims must be substantiated by scientifically verified evidence. What exactly constitutes "verified scientific findings" is regularly a matter of dispute in legal proceedings. Furthermore the HWG imposes strict requirements regarding the permissibility of advertising aimed at the general public. Advertising to the general public using doctors' recommendations, before-and-after pictures or patient testimonials can easily cross the line into unauthorised advertising aimed at the general public – and risk breaking the law (see for example section 11 HWG).
Advertising medical devices: Restrictions under the MDR
For medical devices there is an additional requirement: Article 7 of the Medical Devices Regulation (EU) 2017/745 (MDR) prohibits misleading information in the labelling, instructions for use, making available, putting into service and advertising of medical devices. A statement is considered misleading according to this provision in particular if it ascribes functions or properties to the device which it does not in fact have or if it creates a false impression regarding treatment or diagnostic results. Companies are also prohibited from withholding information from the user regarding relevant risks associated with the intended use and from advertising the product for purposes that go beyond the intended use as defined in the conformity assessment.
For preventive healthcare in practice, this means that advertising a medical device – such as a diagnostic or monitoring device – with effects that are not covered by the intended purpose documented in the conformity assessment procedure is in breach of Article 7 of the MDR, irrespective of the German Unfair Competition Act (UWG) or German Act on Advertising in the Field of Health (HWG). Particularly in the case of products with medical claims – such as wearables designed to "detect" or "prevent" diseases – it is therefore worth carrying out a careful comparison between the advertising message and the documented intended purpose.
Special case – food and food supplements: The Health Claims Regulation
In the food sector, and particularly in the food supplements sector, the Health Claims Regulation (EC) No 1924/2006 also imposes significant restrictions on advertising. This Regulation largely determines which health and nutrition claims may be made for food and food supplements. The Health Claims Regulation follows a strict logic: Specific health and nutrition claims are generally prohibited unless they appear on a relevant list of authorised claims in the Annex to the Regulation. Using claims that are not listed or whose content goes beyond the listed claims risks breaching the regulation – regardless of whether the claim appears to be scientifically plausible.
What advertising is permitted depends on the product category
Which advertising messages are permitted therefore depends on how the product or service is classified according to regulations. If a company is unaware of this classification or classifies the product incorrectly, it will be unable to determine the permissible scope of advertising – and may as a result face difficulties that could have been avoided.
Advertising preventive healthcare: Compliance as a competitive advantage
Marketing departments may view legal requirements as a barrier to creativity. In fact the opposite is true: By being familiar with the legal framework, they can communicate more persuasively and credibly within that framework than competitors who rely on legally dubious superlatives. Particularly in the preventive healthcare market, where consumers are becoming increasingly critical and well-informed, reputable, evidence-based communication can be a genuine differentiating factor.
Legal compliance also pays off financially: Cease-and-desist proceedings triggered by formal warnings are costly affairs, incurring legal fees, attention from management and damage to reputation. Often these losses are many times more than what a preventative legal review of the marketing strategy would have cost.