Proposed EU Digital Fairness Act may be the one regulation to rule them all
Please confirm you are human to start the audio.
The European Commission’s proposed Digital Fairness Act (DFA) is much more than a new rulebook for dark patterns and online subscriptions.
If adopted in its current form, the DFA would repeal and replace the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (UCPD) with a directly applicable EU Regulation covering business-to-consumer commercial practices both online and offline. That is the real “one Regulation to rule them all” feature – the DFA would absorb the familiar unfair commercial practices regime, retain the core rules on misleading and aggressive practices, and add a new digital fairness layer on top, making it relevant not only for platforms and app developers, but for any consumer-facing business that relies on digital design, advertising, subscriptions, personalisation, customer journeys or online sales.
The following article discusses the implications of the proposed DFA and what it means specifically for the Netherlands.
From directive to directly applicable regulation
The current UCPD is a maximum harmonisation directive that has long served as the EU’s general safety net for unfair business-to-consumer commercial practices. The DFA would change that architecture by converting the substantive law on unfair commercial practices into directly applicable EU law, replacing 27 national transposition regimes and reducing room for divergent interpretation. The proposal was published on 11 November 2026 as part of a wider Consumer Package, alongside a Simplification Directive and a proposed revision of the Consumer Protection Cooperation (CPC) framework. It remains a Commission proposal and must still pass through the ordinary EU legislative process involving the European Parliament and the Council.
A new layer in the EU digital rulebook
The DFA is intended to sit alongside the Digital Services Act (DSA), Digital Markets Act, the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), AI Act, Audiovisual Media Services Directive and the proposed EU KIDS Act.
The proposal states that more specific EU rules will prevail in the event of conflict, but many businesses will need to assess the same interface, algorithm, advertising practice or customer journey under several instruments at once.
The relationship between the DFA and the DSA is particularly unclear for dark patterns. Article 25 DSA already prohibits online platforms from designing interfaces that deceive or manipulate users, but it gives way where a practice is covered by consumer law or the GDPR. In practice, the line is thin. Given the broad interpretation of “transactional decision”, almost any manipulative interface aimed at consumers on a commercial platform can be framed as an unfair B2C commercial practice, supplanting the DSA’s Article 25. The DSA provision retains clearer independent relevance for platform interfaces aimed at business users. For consumer-facing dark patterns, the real question is not which rule applies, but which authority enforces it: the Commission under the DSA or consumer authorities and the Commission under the DFA and the revised CPC framework.
The enforcement dimension is important. The parallel CPC reform would allow more centralised Commission enforcement in certain large-scale cross-border cases, and the DFA proposal contemplates fines of up to 6% of worldwide annual turnover for Commission-investigated infringements under the revised CPC framework. The proposal also introduces disclosure-of-evidence powers relating to the design, operation and consumer impact of online commercial practices. Design documentation, A/B testing rationales and internal approval records may therefore become important in future investigations.
What the proposal targets
The DFA’s digital fairness chapter addresses practices that the Commission considers insufficiently covered, or insufficiently clear, under existing consumer law. Dark patterns are tackled through a general prohibition on online interfaces that deceive, manipulate or otherwise materially distort consumer behaviour, combined with a blacklist that the Commission would update by delegated act.
This is particularly relevant in the Netherlands where the ACM’s online consumer guidance already treats manipulative interface design as a consumer law issue and has used that approach in areas such as countdown timers, fake discounts and online games.
Addictive design receives a more nuanced treatment. The proposal would not ban all features such as autoplay, infinite scrolling or engagement prompts for adults, but would require traders to provide effective tools to disable features that encourage compulsive or excessive use. That approach has already drawn criticism from policymakers and civil society actors who argue that safer defaults would be more effective than opt-out tools.
Influencer marketing is another major theme. The proposal would require commercial content to be disclosed clearly and prominently using terms such as “advertisement” or “commercial collaboration”. It would also impose responsibilities not only on influencers, but on brands, advertisers and agencies in the marketing chain. This follows concerns in the Commission’s preparatory work about transparency, unsafe promoted products and uncertainty over responsibility beyond the influencer. The proposal also addresses personalisation, AI-enabled consumer interactions and automated contracting.
Personalised advertising based on profiling would be restricted for minors and special-category data while personalised pricing based on profiling would be prohibited where it is reasonably likely to harm minors or vulnerable consumers. For automated systems and AI agents contracting on behalf of consumers, the proposal would require consumer control over parameters such as prior confirmation and maximum prices, and would prohibit traders from forcing consumers to use such systems to access or conclude transactions.
This sits alongside the broader EU AI framework where the Dutch Data Protection Authority has stressed transparency, risk management and responsible deployment for generative AI.
Digital subscriptions, free trials and customer service are treated in detail. The DFA would require reminders and express consent before a free trial becomes paid, renewal reminders for certain subscription contracts, an online termination function, an online withdrawal function and access to a human being where online customer service does not resolve the issue.
The proposal is also significant for gaming and in-app monetisation. Traders offering paid virtual currencies would have to disclose the corresponding real-money value of virtual items. Paid variable reward systems such as loot boxes would require probability information and disabling tools, and such systems, pay-to-win and pay-to-progress mechanisms would be restricted for minors.
Dutch context is especially relevant given the ACM’s Fortnite enforcement and the Rotterdam court’s confirmation that certain in-game design and advertising practices directed at children could qualify as unfair commercial practices.
Why the average consumer still matters
The DFA does not abandon the “average consumer” concept. The Court of Justice’s Compass Banca judgment confirms that the average consumer remains “reasonably informed, reasonably observant and circumspect” while recognising that cognitive biases could affect consumer behaviour. That matters for digital design cases because dark patterns, scarcity cues, default settings and personalised nudges are often built around behavioural biases rather than simple misinformation. The challenge will be to turn that more realistic benchmark into rules that businesses can apply before launching consumer-facing designs.
Implications for the Netherlands
For the Netherlands, the DFA would interact with an already active enforcement and policy environment. The ACM’s Online Consumer Protection Guidelines give concrete content to the Dutch enforcement standard for online deception, and the ACM has linked that guidance to enforcement in areas such as fake discounts, countdown timers, fake reviews, personalisation, in-game purchases and subscription cancellation.
Dutch public authorities have also been active in Brussels. The Dutch government submitted a non-paper calling primarily for effective enforcement of existing digital rules such as the DSA and for greater coherence between consumer law and the DSA while also advocating targeted measures against harmful design techniques, including addictive design and manipulative practices in games. The ACM responded to the Commission’s consultation with position papers on digital fairness and gaming, supporting the initiative while emphasising simplification, defragmentation and stronger EU-level enforcement. Public affairs commentary also expects the Netherlands to support the DFA while taking a critical stance on proportionality, effectiveness and practical feasibility.
What can businesses do now?
Businesses should begin mapping where the proposal may affect consumer journeys. In practice, that means reviewing sign-up and cancellation flows, renewal reminders, free trials, checkout interfaces, scarcity and urgency messaging, ranking and recommendation systems, influencer arrangements, personalised advertising and pricing, in-game monetisation, AI chatbot escalation and automated contracting tools.
Companies should also think about evidence: being able to explain why a design choice was made, how it was tested and how consumer risks were assessed may become essential.
Our perspective
The DFA is not merely another sector-specific digital law. It is a potential reframing of EU unfair commercial practices law into a directly applicable regulation with a digital fairness chapter reaching into product design, advertising, monetisation and customer lifecycle management.
For businesses, the practical message is clear: monitor the legislative negotiations, engage where necessary, and align consumer-facing design choices with the direction of travel. The proposal may still change, but the policy direction is unmistakable: digital fairness is moving from guidance and enforcement theory into hard EU consumer law.
For more information on the proposed DFA and how it may impact your business in the EU and the Netherlands, contact your CMS client partner or the CMS experts who contributed to this article.