International Patent Litigation in Italy
Key contact
-
I. Standing
- Who is entitled to sue for patent infringement?
- Is it possible to join more than one party as a defendant?
- Is it possible to join suppliers or other third parties to the proceedings?
- Is there any time limit in which claims for patent infringement must be brought?
- Is there a requirement to invoke all potentially infringed patents at once?
-
II. Timing and Forum
- In what court are patent litigation proceedings brought in your jurisdiction? Are infringement and validity decided in the same proceedings?
- Does your country take part in the UPC?
- Can a party apply for a declaration of non-infringement?
- How long does it take for a claim to reach a first hearing?
- How long do trials last in patent cases until a first instance decision?
- Do the judges have technical expertise?
- Will the courts stay proceedings pending the outcome of a related opposition at the EPO?
- Can a party file an action for nullification of a patent without being sued for patent infringement?
- Can a party file an action for a FRAND license or a compulsory license?
- Can a party invoke the FRAND defence in patent infringement proceedings? What will be the consequence of a successful FRAND defence? Do the courts determine a (global) FRAND rate?
-
III. Evidence
- Are expert witnesses used by parties to a patent infringement case? Can a party bring its own expert witnesses or do expert witnesses need to be appointed by the court?
- Do the courts allow disclosure/discovery? If yes, what documents does a party have to disclose? Does the court play an active role in deciding the extent of the disclosure exercise?
- Are preliminary discovery or seizure of evidence/ documents available?
- IV. Appeals
- V. Costs
- VI. Alternative Dispute Resolution
-
VII. Remedies
- What remedies are available for patent infringement? Does your jurisdiction provide for automatic injunctions in case of patent infringement?
- On what basis are damages calculated? If damages are based on a reasonable royalty, how is this rate usually calculated?
- Does the court order an enquiry into damages (separate proceedings to determine the level of damages payable)?
- Is it possible to obtain additional remedies if the infringement was deliberate?
- Can the court order a party to recall infringing products? If so, is there a limitation in time?
-
VIII. Injunctions
- Is it possible to obtain a preliminary injunction in your jurisdiction? If so, what are the requirements?
- Is it possible to obtain a without notice injunction?
- How quickly can preliminary injunctions be obtained?
- Is it possible to appeal against a preliminary injunction and if so does this suspend the effect of the injunction?
- If a party is awarded a preliminary injunction are they liable to provide security?
- Are further proceedings on the merits required in order for the court to grant a final injunction?
- Is a cross-border injunction available and in what circumstances?
- Is an Anti-Suit-Injunction (ASI) available and in what circumstances?
jurisdiction
I. Standing
1.Who is entitled to sue for patent infringement?
The proprietor of a patent may bring proceedings for patent infringement. If the patent is owned by two or more parties, in principle each co-owner may start legal action against third parties in order to defend their rights.
Exclusive licensees also have the right to bring proceedings for patent infringement, provided that the infringement is within the scope of the license. The right of non-exclusive licensees to sue (if it is not provided for in the license) is still a controversial issue. However, it is undisputed that they may intervene in proceedings commenced by the patent’s proprietor.
2. Is it possible to join more than one party as a defendant?
Yes, it is possible to join any number of parties as a defendant in the same proceedings. The plaintiff may commence action against more than one party. The Court also has power to add further parties to the proceedings when their appearance is necessary to resolve the dispute.
3. Is it possible to join suppliers or other third parties to the proceedings?
Yes, all the subjects who have taken part in the production and / or distribution chain of infringing products may be joined to the proceedings.
4. Is there any time limit in which claims for patent infringement must be brought?
There is a limitation period of five years from the date of the infringing act in patent infringement claims where damages are sought. However, this limitation period can be extended indefinitely by means of cease-and-desist letters, which have the effect of determining the commencement of a new limitation period.
5. Is there a requirement to invoke all potentially infringed patents at once?
Invoking all potentially infringed patents in the same proceedings is possible if the claims brought by the patent proprietor are directed against only one infringer or, where they are directed against more than one infringer, if they are connected by their subject matter or legal basis.
II. Timing and Forum
6. In what court are patent litigation proceedings brought in your jurisdiction? Are infringement and validity decided in the same proceedings?
In Italy, infringement and invalidity proceedings must be brought before the divisions specialized in entrepreneurial matters of the Court that has territorial jurisdiction (e.g. Court of Rome, Court of Milan etc.). Validity and infringement can be decided in the same proceedings.
7. Does your country take part in the UPC?
Yes, Italy takes part in the UPC.
8. Can a party apply for a declaration of non-infringement?
Yes, it is possible to apply for a declaration of non-in frin-gement, provided that the plaintiff has a legal interest in such a declaration. Such an interest occurs, for example, when a third party alleges that a patent infringement occurred or threatens to commence patent infringement proceedings. A declaration of non-infringement may be requested also by means of urgency proceedings.
9. How long does it take for a claim to reach a first hearing?
Patent litigation in Italy is conducted by means of written submissions and a series of hearings. A compulsory term of 120 days (if the defendant resides in Italy) or 150 days (if the defendant resides outside of Italy) must elapse between the serving of the writ of summons and the first hearing indicated in the summons. However, the first hearing indicated in the summons is usually postponed to a different date according to the availability of the appointed judge.
10. How long do trials last in patent cases until a first instance decision?
Trials in patent cases until a first instance decision takes between 2 to 4 years depending on the complexity of the case and on the duration of the investigation phase.
11. Do the judges have technical expertise?
The Italian Courts have divisions that are composed of judges who are experts in entrepreneurial matters (including IP matters). However, Italian judges do not have scientific qualifications: therefore, technical assessments are usually carried out by experts appointed by the judge in charge of the patent case.
12. Will the courts stay proceedings pending the outcome of a related opposition at the EPO?
Italian law does not contain any specific rule on this. However, according to some Court decisions, rules concerning the stay of litigation proceedings in case of procedures pending before the Italian Office for Patents and Trademarks apply by analogy also in case of procedures pending before the EPO.
13. Can a party file an action for nullification of a patent without being sued for patent infringement?
Yes, an action aimed at obtaining a declaration of nullity of a patent may be exercised by whoever has a legal interest in doing so, independently of the fact that a patent infringement case has been started by a third party. An action aimed at obtaining a declaration of nullity of a patent can be brought also by the competent Public Prosecutor.
14. Can a party file an action for a FRAND license or a compulsory license?
Bringing an action seeking a FRAND license is legally possible. In practice, however, FRAND licensing is more commonly raised as a defense in infringement proceedings brought by the patent proprietor, enabling the defendant to invoke the patent proprietor’s obligation to grant a license to use the patent on FRAND terms.
Compulsory license
According to Italian law, one who wishes to obtain a compulsory license must start proceedings before the Italian Office for Patents and Trademarks, by submitting a grounded request which must indicate the amount and method of payment of the compensation offered.
The Office shall promptly give notice of the request to the patent’s proprietor and to those who have rights on the patent (based on acts that have been registered or annotated). These subjects are entitled to oppose the application or the amount and method of payment of the compensation proposed by the applicant within 60 days. In case of opposition, the Office, within 45 days from the expiry of the above term, shall summon the parties to attempt conciliation. The applicant may file a brief by the fifth day prior to the date of the meeting scheduled for the conciliation attempt. Within 45 days of the meeting the Ministry of Economic Development will decide whether to grant the compulsory licence or reject the application.
The proceedings shall be concluded within 180 days from the filing of the application.
Compulsory licenses may be requested for dependent patents or in case of lack of implementation by the patent’s proprietor or its successor in title. Starting from July 2021 compulsory licenses are possible also in case of national medical emergencies to address proven difficulties in the procurement of specific drugs or medical devices deemed essential. In such a case the license is granted by the Ministry of Health together with the Ministry of Economic Development.
In all the cases indicated above, the party seeking the grant of a compulsory license must prove that it has previously approached the patent’s proprietor and was unable to obtain a contractual license from the latter on fair and reasonable terms.
15. Can a party invoke the FRAND defence in patent infringement proceedings? What will be the consequence of a successful FRAND defence? Do the courts determine a (global) FRAND rate?
Yes, a party can invoke the FRAND defence to paralyse the requests of the patent’s proprietor in patent infringement proceedings. The determination of the FRAND rate by the Courts is legally possible.
III. Evidence
16. Are expert witnesses used by parties to a patent infringement case? Can a party bring its own expert witnesses or do expert witnesses need to be appointed by the court?
Yes, in patent infringement cases parties are entitled to appoint one or more experts to support their arguments and in addition, the judge may appoint its own expert. The judge will only appoint more than one expert in exceptional cases. Both the parties’ experts and the expert appointed by the judge must file written reports containing their technical opinions. If requested by the judge, the experts may also have to appear at oral hearings in order to clarify their findings.
17. Do the courts allow disclosure/discovery? If yes, what documents does a party have to disclose? Does the court play an active role in deciding the extent of the disclosure exercise?
If the production of specified documents is necessary for the resolution of the dispute, upon a party’s request, the Court can order the disclosure / discovery of said documents.
18. Are preliminary discovery or seizure of evidence/ documents available?
Italian law does not provide for preliminary discovery of documents. However, the preliminary description and / or seizure of specific documents is possible and may be authorised by the Court if the documents in question.
IV. Appeals
19. What are the possible routes for appeal in your jurisdiction?
First instance decisions may be challenged before the competent Courts of Appeal. Second instance decisions may be challenged before the Supreme Court. A first instance decision may also be challenged directly before the Supreme Court if the first instance Court wrongly applied legal provisions and the parties agree to renounce the second instance proceedings. An appeal against a first-instance decision must be lodged within 30 days from the service of the decision by the winning party. An appeal against a second instance decision must be filed within 60 days from the service of the decision by the winning party. In both cases, if the decision has not been served, the term is equal to six months from the publication of the decision. The above terms are suspended each year from 1 August to 31 August.
20. On what grounds can an appeal be brought?
An appeal against a first instance decision may be brought if the first instance Court wrongly interpreted the facts or breached the applicable procedural or substantive rules. In the appeal phase, new claims may not be filed, and new objections may not be raised, unless they can also be raised by the court of its own motion. Furthermore, new evidence is not admissible, and new documents may not be submitted, unless the party demonstrates that it was unable to file or produce them in the first instance proceedings for reasons not attributable to it.
At the beginning of the appeal stage, the Court of Appeal must carry out a preliminary assessment. As a consequence of such assessment, if it finds that the appeal is inadmissible or manifestly unfounded, the Court of Appeal orders the oral discussion of the case, at the conclusion of which it issues the decision.
21. What is an approximate timescale for the first/ second appeal?
Approximately five years for the first appeal to the Court of Appeal and two years for a second appeal to the Supreme Court.
22. Is the first instance decision suspended while an appeal is pending?
No, as a general rule, the first instance decision is immediately enforceable, and its enforceability is not suspended while an appeal is pending. However, the Court of Appeal, upon a party's request filed with the principal appeal or with the cross-appeal, shall suspend in whole or in part the enforceability or the enforcement of the appealed decision, with or without security, if the appeal appears manifestly well-founded or if the enforcement of the decision may cause serious and irreparable harm, even where the decision concerns the payment of a sum of money, including in relation to the possible insolvency of either party. The application for suspension may be filed or re-filed during the appeal proceedings if there is a change in circumstances, which must be specifically set out in the application.
V. Costs
23. What would be the estimated legal costs of patent litigation proceedings for a first instance decision?
It is very difficult to estimate the legal costs without knowledge of the case. However, as a general guide, costs for patent litigation proceedings are usually between seventy thousand euros (EUR 70,000) to one hundred and fifty thousand euros (EUR 150,000) for a first instance decision.
24. What would be the estimated legal costs of patent litigation proceedings for an appeal?
As above, it is difficult to estimate these costs without knowledge of the case. However, costs for patent litigation proceedings are usually between fifty thousand euros (EUR 50,000) to one hundred thousand euros (EUR 100,000) for the appeal and approximately equal to eighty thousand euros (EUR 80,000) for the appeal to the Supreme Court.
25. Are litigation costs recoverable? If so, is there a limitation?
As a general rule the judge, in rendering the decision, orders the losing party to reimburse the legal costs and fees anticipated by the winner party. However, based on a case-by-case assessment the judge is entitled to allocate costs and fees differently, for example by deciding that each party shall bear its own costs. The quantification of the legal fees is made by the judge by taking into account the rates indicated by the law.
VI. Alternative Dispute Resolution
26. What are the options for alternative dispute resolution in your jurisdiction? Are these commonly used?
There are two options for alternative dispute resolution: arbitration and mediation. Arbitration is commonly used, but mediation is rarely used in IP matters. In order to submit a dispute to arbitration there must be an arbitration agreement between the parties. The arbitration agreement must be in writing and must clearly set out the subject matter of the dispute.
27. Does the court require that parties consider these options at any stage in proceedings?
No, in IP matters the Court is not required to ask the parties to consider alternative dispute resolution options. However, it may choose to do so.
VII. Remedies
28. What remedies are available for patent infringement? Does your jurisdiction provide for automatic injunctions in case of patent infringement?
The court may order:
- That the defendant ceases the infringing acts;
- The destruction of the infringing goods;
- The assignment of the infringing goods (and / or the machines or tools used to make them) to the claimant;
- The seizure of all infringing goods (and / or the machines or tools used to make them);
- The payment by the infringer of the damages suffered by the patent’s owner;
- The publication of the judgment in newspapers and magazines;
- The payment of penalties for any further infringement.
No, automatic injunctions are not provided by Italian law.
29. On what basis are damages calculated? If damages are based on a reasonable royalty, how is this rate usually calculated?
Damages are assessed by taking into account all the negative economic consequences, including the loss of profit, suffered by the owner of the patent, any unfair profit made by the infringer, and, in some cases, other elements such as moral prejudice.
Any loss of profit awarded must not be lower than the royalties that the infringer would have paid if it had obtained a license from the owner of the patent. There is no specific rate for such royalties. The rate must be assessed by the Court on a case-by-case basis. In any event, the patent’s proprietor can request a refund of the profits made by the infringer as an alternative to compensation for loss of profit or to the extent that such profits exceed said compensation.
30. Does the court order an enquiry into damages (separate proceedings to determine the level of damages payable)?
The party alleging the infringement must prove its occurrence and the extent of damages requested. However, if it is not possible to exactly quantify the damages, they can be assessed by the Court based on an equitable assessment. Separate proceedings to determine the level of damages payable are also possible.
31. Is it possible to obtain additional remedies if the infringement was deliberate?
All the remedies listed above may be ordered by the court regardless of whether the infringer acted intentionally or negligently, with the exception of the remedy of damages. Indeed, according to the prevailing case law, where the infringer acted without intent or negligence, the patent’s proprietor cannot claim full compensation for the damages suffered, but only the refund of the profits derived from the infringement.
32. Can the court order a party to recall infringing products? If so, is there a limitation in time?
An order to recall infringing products from the market may be issued in the judgment that determines the infringement of an industrial property right. No specific limitation in time is provided.
VIII. Injunctions
33. Is it possible to obtain a preliminary injunction in your jurisdiction? If so, what are the requirements?
Yes. However, Courts may grant preliminary injunctions only if the following two requirements are met:
- the probable existence of the right enforced (so-called fumus boni iuris);
- a pending or imminent infringement (so-called periculum in mora).
In this respect, it is recommended that proceedings aimed at obtaining preliminary injunctions are started soon after the awareness of the infringement by the IP rights’ owner. However, according to the majority of case-law, these proceedings may be started even if some time has elapsed from awareness of the infringement, provided that the “market relationships” between the parties (i.e. the parties market shares) are not steady yet.
34. Is it possible to obtain a without notice injunction?
Yes, if serious urgency reasons occur and the involvement of the counterparty in the proceedings could jeopardise the implementation of the Court’s decision, the judge, taking summary information (if necessary), can issue a decree inaudita altera parte (i.e. without notice). However, with the same decree, the judge shall schedule the hearing for the appearance before the Court of all the parties within a term no longer than fifteen days and shall assign to the claimant a term no longer than eight days for the notification of the claim and the decree to the adverse party. At the hearing, the judge may confirm, modify or revoke the decree. If the notification must take place abroad, the terms referred to above are trebled. Italian Courts are very strict in assessing the urgency requirements: therefore, decisions inaudita altera parte are issued only in exceptional cases.
35. How quickly can preliminary injunctions be obtained?
Preliminary injunctions are obtained within approximately 2 to 4 months from the filing of the application. However, the achievement of a preliminary injunction in patent cases, where technical investigations are usually required, can take longer.
36. Is it possible to appeal against a preliminary injunction and if so does this suspend the effect of the injunction?
An appeal against a preliminary injunction can be filed within 15 days from the date the preliminary injunction was granted at the hearing or from the date the injunction was served or communicated. The appeal does not automatically suspend the effect of the injunction. However, suspension of the injunction may be ordered by the Court when its enforcement could cause serious damage.
37. If a party is awarded a preliminary injunction are they liable to provide security?
If a party is awarded a preliminary injunction, it is not automatically liable to provide security. However, the Court may order the successful party to provide security if it is appropriate based on a case-by-case assessment.
38. Are further proceedings on the merits required in order for the court to grant a final injunction?
To prevent preliminary injunctions from losing their effect, merit proceedings must be commenced within the term established by the judge in issuing the preliminary injunctions. If no term is established by the judge, merit proceedings must commence within the term of 20 working days or 31 calendar days if these represent a longer period. The term runs from the pronouncement of the preliminary injunction if it is made at the hearing or, otherwise, from its communication. With respect to preliminary injunctions capable of anticipating the effects of the decision on the merits, without prejudice to the parties' right to commence proceedings on the merits, where such proceedings are not commenced within the aforementioned mandatory time limit, or where they are subsequently discontinued, the injunctions shall be declared ineffective if, within the mandatory time limit of 30 days running from the expiry of the aforementioned time limit or from the discontinuance of the proceedings on the merits, the party against whom the injunctions were issued files an application for a declaration of ineffectiveness.
39. Is a cross-border injunction available and in what circumstances?
No. Decisions of the national Courts only have effect within Italy.
40. Is an Anti-Suit-Injunction (ASI) available and in what circumstances?
No, Anti-Suit-Injunction is not available under Italian law.