International Patent Litigation in Norway
Key contacts
-
I. Standing
- Who is entitled to sue for patent infringement?
- Is it possible to join more than one party as a defendant?
- Is it possible to join suppliers or other third parties to the proceedings?
- Is there any time limit in which claims for patent infringement must be brought?
- Is there a requirement to invoke all potentially infringed patents at once?
-
II. Timing and Forum
- In what court are patent litigation proceedings brought in your jurisdiction? Are infringement and validity decided in the same proceedings?
- Does your country take part in the UPC?
- Can a party apply for a declaration of non-infringement?
- How long does it take for a claim to reach a first hearing?
- How long do trials last in patent cases until a first instance decision?
- Do the judges have technical expertise?
- Will the courts stay proceedings pending the outcome of a related opposition at the EPO?
- Can a party file an action for nullification of a patent without being sued for patent infringement?
- Can a party file an action for a FRAND license or a compulsory license?
- Can a party invoke the FRAND defence in patent infringement proceedings? What will be the consequence of a successful FRAND defence? Do the courts determine a (global) FRAND rate?
-
III. Evidence
- Are expert witnesses used by parties to a patent infringement case? Can a party bring its own expert witnesses or do expert witnesses need to be appointed by the court?
- Do the courts allow disclosure/discovery? If yes, what documents does a party have to disclose? Does the court play an active role in deciding the extent of the disclosure exercise?
- Are preliminary discovery or seizure of evidence/ documents available?
- IV. Appeals
- V. Costs
- VI. Alternative Dispute Resolution
-
VII Remedies
- What remedies are available for patent infringement? Does your jurisdiction provide for automatic injunctions in case of patent infringement?
- On what basis are damages calculated? If damages are based on a reasonable royalty, how is this rate usually calculated?
- Does the court order an enquiry into damages (separate proceedings to determine the level of damages payable)?
- Is it possible to obtain additional remedies if the infringement was deliberate?
- Can the court order a party to recall infringing products? If so, is there a limitation in time?
-
VIII Injunctions
- Is it possible to obtain a preliminary injunction in your jurisdiction? If so, what are the requirements?
- Is it possible to obtain a without notice injunction?
- How quickly can preliminary injunctions be obtained?
- Is it possible to appeal against a preliminary injunction and if so does this suspend the effect of the injunction?
- If a party is awarded a preliminary injunction are they liable to provide security?
- Are further proceedings on the merits required in order for the court to grant a final injunction?
- Is a cross-border injunction available and in what circumstances?
- Is an Anti-Suit-Injunction (ASI) available and in what circumstances?
jurisdiction
I. Standing
1.Who is entitled to sue for patent infringement?
The patent proprietor is generally entitled to sue for infringement. To establish standing, it is usually enough to assert ownership of the patent, while any dispute over ownership is addressed on the merits rather than at the admissibility stage.
A licensee may also bring an infringement action, provided that the patent proprietor has first been notified by registered letter. In this respect, the Patents Act does not distinguish between exclusive and non-exclusive licensees.
Where two or more parties are proprietors of the same patent, the Patents Act does not specify whether one co-owner may independently bring infringement proceedings. The issue is therefore governed by any agreement between the co-owners and the general Co-ownership Act. Absent agreement to the contrary, case law under the Co-ownership Act suggests that each co-owner may sue independently to protect the patent, although this has not been tested specifically in the patent context.
2. Is it possible to join more than one party as a defendant?
Yes. Under Norwegian civil procedure, multiple parties may be sued in the same proceedings, provided that the relevant jurisdictional and procedural requirements are satisfied and either no party objects or the claims are so closely connected that they should be heard together.
3. Is it possible to join suppliers or other third parties to the proceedings?
Yes. A party may, in the course of the proceedings, bring claims against a third party who is not already part of the case, provided the claims are sufficiently closely connected. A third party may also intervene if it wishes to assert an independent claim relating to the subject matter of the dispute, or a claim closely connected to it. The court may refuse joinder if it would cause significant delay or make the proceedings unduly complex.
4. Is there any time limit in which claims for patent infringement must be brought?
Yes, but the position depends on the type of relief sought. A claim for injunctive relief may in principle be brought at any time during the life of the patent. By contrast, monetary claims arising from infringement, such as claims for damage, are subject to the general rules on limitation. For damages claims, the limitation period is three years from the date on which the claimant obtained, or ought to have obtained, the knowledge necessary to bring the claim, subject to an absolute long-stop period of 20 years from the date the infringing act ceased. For claims relating to exploitation before the patent was granted, the limitation period does not begin to run until the patent has been granted.
5. Is there a requirement to invoke all potentially infringed patents at once?
Norwegian law does not provide a general rule requiring a claimant to rely on all potentially infringed patents in the same proceedings. The binding effect of a final judgment is confined to the specific claim that the court has decided. Claims based on different patents will often be treated as separate claims, even where they arise from the same allegedly infringing conduct, though they may in some cases be regarded as the same claim if sufficiently closely linked. This must be determined on the basis of a concrete assessment of the particular circumstances.
II. Timing and Forum
6. In what court are patent litigation proceedings brought in your jurisdiction? Are infringement and validity decided in the same proceedings?
Although Norway’s court system is generally based on ordinary courts, the Patents Act centralizes all civil patent infringement and invalidity actions before the Oslo District Court, which has exclusive jurisdiction. Norway does not operate a bifurcated system, and issues of infringement and validity may therefore be determined in the same proceedings before the same court. In practice, a defendant in infringement proceedings will typically challenge the patent’s validity by way of counterclaim or by bringing a separate invalidity action, which may then be joined with the infringement action.
7. Does your country take part in the UPC?
No. Norway is not an EU member state and does therefore not participate in the Unified Patent Court (UPC) system.
8. Can a party apply for a declaration of non-infringement?
Under Norwegian procedural law, declaratory actions may be brought where the claimant has a sufficient legal interest in obtaining judicial clarification of a concrete and current dispute. Applied to patent cases, this means that a party may seek a declaration that a specific product or activity does not infringe a patent.
9. How long does it take for a claim to reach a first hearing?
The time required for a patent case to reach the main hearing will generally depend on the complexity of the case and the court’s workload. In practice, patent cases before the Oslo District Court typically proceed to a main hearing within six months to one year of filing, although more complex cases may take longer.
10. How long do trials last in patent cases until a first instance decision?
Patent trials in Norway are typically among the more complex civil proceedings and often extend over one to two weeks of court hearings, depending on the technical complexity of the case, the number of patents and claims in dispute, and the volume of expert and witness evidence. Highly complex cases, particularly in the pharmaceutical sector, can run considerably longer.
A first instance decision from Oslo District Court is usually issued within a few months after the conclusion of the main hearing, although complex cases may take longer.
11. Do the judges have technical expertise?
No. Norwegian judges are legally trained generalist judges and are not required to have any technical or scientific background. Although patent cases are concentrated before the Oslo District Court and are handled by a smaller group of judges with a moderate IP-specialization, who also builds experience in this area over time – they do however remain generalist judges rather than technical specialists. To address technical issues, the court may (and almost always will, depending on the opinion of the parties) appoint expert lay judges with relevant technical qualifications to sit alongside the professional judges. The court may also appoint independent technical experts to assist on technical questions arising in the case, but this rarely happens as the lay judges and the parties’ technical witnesses generally serve to shed sufficient light og the technical aspects of the case.
12. Will the courts stay proceedings pending the outcome of a related opposition at the EPO?
Norwegian courts have a general discretion under the Dispute Act to stay proceedings where the outcome may depend, wholly or partly, on an issue to be determined in another matter, or where there are otherwise compelling reasons to do so. As the Patents Act contains no specific rules on stays pending EPO opposition proceedings, the question is governed by this general procedural discretion. A stay may be warranted where the outcome of the opposition is likely to have a material bearing on the issues before the court, for example because revocation or amendment of the patent would affect the infringement or validity assessment. This is particularly relevant given that a decision revoking or limiting a European patent takes effect automatically in Norway. Norwegian courts have however in several instances chosen not to stay proceedings pending the outcome of related EPO-matters due to the EPO’s long processing times.
13. Can a party file an action for nullification of a patent without being sued for patent infringement?
Yes. An action for invalidity may be brought independently, without any requirement that infringement proceedings have first commenced. In addition, any person may request administrative invalidation of a patent before the Norwegian Industrial Property Office.
14. Can a party file an action for a FRAND license or a compulsory license?
FRAND license: Norwegian law contains no specific procedural framework for actions seeking the grant of a FRAND license or the determination of FRAND terms. There also appears to be no reported Norwegian case law in which a court has ordered the grant of a FRAND license or determined the terms of such a license. Such a claim would therefore have to be brought under the ordinary rules of civil procedure, but there is currently no established Norwegian practice as to how the courts would approach such proceedings.
Compulsory license: Yes. Under the Patents Act, a compulsory license may be sought either through court proceedings before the Oslo District Court or, in certain circumstances, by application to the Norwegian Competition Authority. Compulsory licenses are available only on limited statutory grounds, including where the patented invention is not being sufficiently exploited, where exploitation of a later patent depends on an earlier patent, or where important public interests or competition considerations justify such a license. If a compulsory license is granted, the competent authority determines the scope and terms of the license, including appropriate remuneration.
15. Can a party invoke the FRAND defence in patent infringement proceedings? What will be the consequence of a successful FRAND defence? Do the courts determine a (global) FRAND rate?
There are no specific statutory provisions or reported Norwegian decisions addressing the availability or effect of a FRAND defense in patent infringement proceedings. Accordingly, there is no established Norwegian practice regarding the procedural or substantive consequences of such a defense, and Norwegian courts have not determined FRAND license terms or a national or global FRAND royalty rate.
III. Evidence
16. Are expert witnesses used by parties to a patent infringement case? Can a party bring its own expert witnesses or do expert witnesses need to be appointed by the court?
Yes, expert witnesses are commonly used in patent cases in Norway. Under the Dispute Act, there are two categories of expert evidence. First, the court may appoint one or more court-appointed experts when this is necessary to obtain a sound factual basis for the decision. The court determines the expert’s mandate and instructions. Second, each party may independently present its own expert witnesses without court appointment. A party’s expert witnesses give evidence under the same rules as ordinary witnesses, but may be present throughout the proceedings.
17. Do the courts allow disclosure/discovery? If yes, what documents does a party have to disclose? Does the court play an active role in deciding the extent of the disclosure exercise?
Norway does not have a broad discovery regime comparable to that in common law jurisdictions. However, the Dispute Act imposes certain disclosure obligations. Each party has a general duty to disclose important evidence relevant to the case, including evidence unfavorable to the disclosing party, if the other party cannot reasonably be expected to know about it. Any person may also be ordered to make available objects or documents in their possession as evidence, but the requesting party must specify which items of evidence it seeks. The court plays an active role in determining the scope of any disclosure and may refuse requests where the costs are disproportionate to the significance of the dispute or the likely value of the evidence.
In IP infringement cases specifically, the Dispute Act also provides a right to obtain information about the origin and distribution network of infringing goods, which may be ordered against the infringer and certain third parties involved in the distribution chain.
18. Are preliminary discovery or seizure of evidence/ documents available?
Yes. Under the Dispute Act, a party may apply for preservation of evidence before proceedings are commenced if there is an imminent risk that evidence will be lost or significantly weakened, or if it is otherwise particularly important to obtain access to evidence at an early stage. The application is made to the competent district court.
Preservation may be conducted immediately where rapid implementation is necessary. Where possible, the opposing party should be notified beforehand, but the court may order preservation without prior notice if there is reason to fear that notification would prevent the evidence from being secured. If preservation is ordered without notice, the opposing party is not informed until the preservation has been completed.
The applicant may be required to provide security and may be liable in damages if the application turns out to be unfounded.
IV. Appeals
19. What are the possible routes for appeal in your jurisdiction?
A first instance judgment from Oslo District Court may be appealed to the Borgarting Court of Appeal, which is also based in Oslo. A judgment from the Court of Appeal may in turn be appealed to the Supreme Court of Norway, but only if leave to appeal is granted. Leave to appeal to the Supreme Court is only given where the case raises issues of significance beyond the individual case or where there are other special reasons making it important that the Supreme Court decides the matter. As a rule of thumb, the Supreme Courts grants leave to appeal in roughly one tenth of the cases it receives.
20. On what grounds can an appeal be brought?
An appeal to the Court of Appeal may be based on errors in the assessment of the facts, errors of law, or procedural errors in the first instance proceedings. The appeal constitutes a full rehearing of the case, meaning new evidence may be introduced and witnesses may be heard again.
An appeal to the Supreme Court is more limited in scope. As leave to appeal is generally granted only in cases raising questions of principle or otherwise of particular importance, the review is in practice usually confined to questions of law.
21. What is an approximate timescale for the first/ second appeal?
The processing time for appeals to the Court of Appeal varies depending on the complexity of the case, the amount of evidence involved and the court’s workload. As a general estimate, civil appeals typically take approximately 6-18 months from filing of the appeal until the appeal hearing. Complex IP disputes, including patent cases involving extensive technical evidence, may take longer.
Appeals to the Supreme Court require prior leave from the Appeals Selection Committee. If leave is granted, the Supreme Court process typically takes approximately 6-12 months from admission to judgment, although the timeframe may vary depending on the complexity and importance of the case.
22. Is the first instance decision suspended while an appeal is pending?
As a general rule under the Enforcement Act, a judgment cannot be enforced until it has become final. Accordingly, where the judgment grants non-monetary relief – such as an injunction prohibiting infringement – an appeal will normally have full suspensive effect.
A different rule applies to judgments for the payment of money. Although such judgments are not ordinarily enforceable pending appeal, the creditor may, before the judgment becomes final, seek attachment in the debtor’s assets as security for the claim, unless the debtor provides adequate security. In practice, this means that an appeal will usually suspend enforcement of the operative relief, but may not prevent interim measures aimed at securing a monetary claim while the appeal is pending.
V. Costs
23. What would be the estimated legal costs of patent litigation proceedings for a first instance decision?
It is difficult to provide a reliable estimate, as costs depend on the technical complexity of the case, the number of expert witnesses, and the length of the trial. However, based on experience, each party’s legal costs for first instance proceedings typically range from approximately EUR 100,000-300,000 in moderately complex cases to EUR 500,000-900,000 in highly complex cases (such as major pharmaceutical patent disputes). These figures include legal fees, costs for technical experts, and court fees.
24. What would be the estimated legal costs of patent litigation proceedings for an appeal?
Costs for appeals to the Court of Appeal are typically somewhat lower than in the first instance, as much of the preparatory work will already have been done. However, since an appeal constitutes a full rehearing, costs may approach first instance levels if the appeal involves substantial new evidence and witnesses. The actual costs therefore depend heavily on how the appeal is framed by the parties.
Appeals to the Supreme Court tend to involve lower costs as they are typically limited to questions of law, with costs in the range of EUR 30,000-60,000 per party.
25. Are litigation costs recoverable? If so, is there a limitation?
Yes. Under the Dispute Act, the general rule is that the losing party must reimburse the winning party’s full litigation costs. Exceptions to this cost-shifting rule may apply where the case raised genuine doubt or where the losing party had reasonable grounds to litigate, but such exceptions are rarely applied in patent cases between well-resourced parties.
As to the amount recoverable, the court assesses what costs were necessary and reasonable for the proper conduct of the case. In practice, Norwegian courts allow considerable latitude in patent cases, recognizing that such cases require specialized legal counsel with high hourly rates and substantial preparatory work. However, courts do reduce cost awards where they consider the claimed amount to exceed what was necessary – for example by reducing the number of hours claimed or capping hourly rates.
VI. Alternative Dispute Resolution
26. What are the options for alternative dispute resolution in your jurisdiction? Are these commonly used?
The main forms of alternative dispute resolution in Norway are negotiation, mediation and arbitration. In practice, negotiation is the most common, both before and during proceedings. Mediation may take place informally between the parties or as court-annexed mediation, which is available in civil cases and is conducted either by a judge or by an external mediator appointed by the court. A settlement reached through court-annexed mediation has the same legally binding effect as a court judgment. Arbitration is also available where the parties have agreed to submit their dispute to arbitration, and is governed by the Norwegian Arbitration Act.
In patent disputes, negotiated settlements do occur, but mediation and arbitration are relatively uncommon in patent infringement matters in Norway, as the parties generally will have made serious efforts at negotiations before the suit is filed.
27. Does the court require that parties consider these options at any stage in proceedings?
Yes. Under the Dispute Act, the court is required at every stage of the proceedings to consider whether the dispute may be resolved amicably through mediation or court-annexed mediation. The court may order mediation where it considers the case suitable for it, taking into account the parties’ attitude and the prospects of reaching a settlement. However, the court cannot compel the parties to settle, and parties may decline to participate in mediation if they do not consider it appropriate.
VII Remedies
28. What remedies are available for patent infringement? Does your jurisdiction provide for automatic injunctions in case of patent infringement?
The remedies available for patent infringement under the Patents Act include:
- injunctive relief prohibiting the infringer from repeating the infringing acts, including in cases where a person has made substantial preparations to commit infringement;
- damages or other financial compensation;
- preventive measures, such as recall from the market, definitive removal from the market, destruction of infringing products, or delivery of such products to the right holder.
In addition, patent infringement constitutes a criminal offence punishable by fines or imprisonment. In practice, however, these provisions are rarely invoked, and criminal enforcement plays only a very limited role in Norwegian patent disputes.
Norwegian law does not provide for automatic injunctions in patent infringement cases. An injunction may be granted only if specifically requested by the patent holder, as the court may not award relief beyond the parties’ claims. Where infringement is established and injunctive relief has been sought, the court will grant an injunction.
29. On what basis are damages calculated? If damages are based on a reasonable royalty, how is this rate usually calculated?
In cases of negligent or intentional infringement, the right holder may claim compensation on the basis most favorable to it, choosing between the following alternatives:
- a reasonable royalty for the exploitation, plus damages for any additional loss that would not have occurred under a license;
- damages for the loss caused by the infringement; or
- an amount corresponding to the infringer’s profits from the infringement.
Where compensation is claimed on the basis of a reasonable royalty, this is assessed by reference to the amount the infringer would have had to pay had it obtained a license. In practice, the royalty rate is determined on the basis of practice between the parties, if relevant, comparable license agreements, industry practice, and expert evidence.
Where the infringement was intentional or grossly negligent, the right holder may instead claim double the reasonable royalty. For good faith infringement, the infringer must pay a reasonable royalty or surrender profits to the extent this is not unreasonable.
30. Does the court order an enquiry into damages (separate proceedings to determine the level of damages payable)?
Norwegian courts do not typically order a separate enquiry into damages as a distinct procedural step. Damages are normally determined in the same proceedings as liability. However, the court may in practice bifurcate the proceedings by first deciding liability and then, if infringement is found, addressing the quantum of damages at a later stage or inviting the parties to settle the damages claim.
31. Is it possible to obtain additional remedies if the infringement was deliberate?
Yes. As stated above; where the infringement was intentional or grossly negligent, the right holder may claim double the reasonable royalty as compensation, instead of the normal calculation methods.
In addition, deliberate patent infringement is a criminal offence, and the right holder may request criminal prosecution. Where there are particularly aggravating circumstances – taking into account the damage caused to the right holder, the profits obtained by the infringer, and the overall scale of the infringement – the penalty may be increased to imprisonment of up to three years. This is however very uncommon.
32. Can the court order a party to recall infringing products? If so, is there a limitation in time?
Yes. The court may order the recall of infringing products from the market, their permanent removal from the market, their destruction, or their delivery to the right holder. The same applies to materials and tools primarily used or intended for the production of infringing products. The choice of measure is subject to a proportionality assessment, taking into account the seriousness of the infringement, the effects of the measure, and the interests of third parties. The measures are carried out at the infringer’s expense unless special reasons dictate otherwise.
The Patents Act does not specify a time limit for recall orders. Unlike monetary claims, non-monetary remedies such as injunctions and recall orders are generally not subject to the statutory limitation periods, but may in exceptional cases be limited by the doctrine of passivity.
VIII Injunctions
33. Is it possible to obtain a preliminary injunction in your jurisdiction? If so, what are the requirements?
Yes. A preliminary injunction may be obtained under the Norwegian Dispute Act. The applicant must demonstrate (i) a claim (i.e. a right that is being infringed or threatened), and (ii) a need for interim relief – either that the defendant’s conduct makes it necessary to secure the claim because enforcement would otherwise be substantially impeded, or that a temporary order is necessary to avert substantial harm or inconvenience. Both the claim and the grounds for relief must be made probable. The court will, however, refuse a preliminary injunction if the harm or inconvenience to the defendant would be manifestly disproportionate to the applicant’s interest in obtaining the injunction.
In addition, Norwegian law provides for border enforcement measures in IP cases. Upon application by the right holder, the court may order the customs authorities to detain goods suspected of infringing intellectual property rights pending further proceedings.
34.Is it possible to obtain a without notice injunction?
Yes. Where there is a risk of harm from delay, the court may grant a preliminary injunction without holding oral proceedings and without prior notice to the defendant. If such an order is made, the defendant and other affected parties must be informed of their right to request a subsequent hearing, at which the court may confirm, modify, or revoke the injunction.
35. How quickly can preliminary injunctions be obtained?
Where urgency is established, a preliminary injunction may be obtained within days. In cases decided without oral hearing, a decision can in principle be made immediately upon the court receiving the application. Where a hearing is required, the timeframe will depend on the court’s schedule, but the court is expected to act expeditiously in urgent matters.
36. Is it possible to appeal against a preliminary injunction and if so does this suspend the effect of the injunction?
If a preliminary injunction is granted after oral proceedings, the decision may be appealed. However, if it was granted without oral proceedings, the parties may not appeal but must instead request a subsequent oral hearing before the same court, which will then reconsider the matter.
An appeal does not automatically suspend the effect of the preliminary injunction – the injunction remains in force unless the appellate court orders otherwise. A decision to revoke a preliminary injunction does not take effect until it becomes final, unless the defendant provides security for the claim.
37. If a party is awarded a preliminary injunction are they liable to provide security?
The court may require the applicant to provide security for potential damages to the defendant as a condition for the injunction taking effect. If the injunction is subsequently revoked and it turns out that the applicant’s claim did not exist, the applicant is liable for the damage suffered by the defendant as a result of the injunction. The court determines the amount of any required security.
38. Are further proceedings on the merits required in order for the court to grant a final injunction?
A preliminary injunction is by nature temporary. The court may set a deadline for the applicant to commence proceedings on the merits. If such a deadline is set and the applicant fails to comply, the preliminary injunction falls away. For a permanent (final) injunction, the right holder must obtain a judgment on the merits. The court may, however, allow the merits of the case to be decided simultaneously with the application for interim relief if the case is suitable for it.
39. Is a cross-border injunction available and in what circumstances?
No. Norwegian courts generally grant injunctions only in respect of infringements of Norwegian patent rights within Norway. Patent rights are territorial, and there is no established practice of Norwegian courts granting cross-border patent injunctions. While interim measures ordered by Norwegian courts may, in certain circumstances, be recognized and enforced in other states under the Lugano Convention, the Convention does not provide a basis for granting injunctions with cross-border substantive effect.
40. Is an Anti-Suit-Injunction (ASI) available and in what circumstances?
There is no established practice of Norwegian courts granting anti-suit injunctions. Norwegian procedural law does not contain specific provisions addressing ASIs, and no reported case law on ASIs in patent disputes has been identified. Given Norway’s adherence to principles of international comity and the absence of any statutory basis, it is unlikely that Norwegian courts would grant ASIs, particularly in disputes involving parties in other EEA states where such orders could conflict with European principles of mutual trust between courts.