International Patent Litigation in Portugal
Key contacts
-
I. Standing
- Who is entitled to sue for patent infringement?
- Is it possible to join more than one party as a defendant?
- Is it possible to join suppliers or other third parties to the proceedings?
- Is there any time limit in which claims for patent infringement must be brought?
- Is there a requirement to invoke all potentially infringed patents at once?
-
II. Timing and Forum
- In what court are patent litigation proceedings brought in your jurisdiction? Are infringement and validity decided in the same proceedings?
- Does your country take part in the UPC?
- Can a party apply for a declaration of non-infringement?
- How long does it take for a claim to reach a first hearing?
- How long do trials last in patent cases until a first instance decision?
- Do the judges have technical expertise?
- Will the courts stay proceedings pending the outcome of a related opposition at the EPO?
- Can a party file an action for nullification of a patent without being sued for patent infringement?
- Can a party file an action for a FRAND license or a compulsory license?
- Can a party invoke the FRAND defence in patent infringement proceedings?
- III. Evidence
- IV. Appeals
- V. Costs
- VI. Alternative Dispute Resolution
-
VII. Remedies
- What remedies are available for patent infringement? Does your jurisdiction provide for automatic injunctions?
- On what basis are damages calculated?
- Does the court order an enquiry into damages?
- Is it possible to obtain additional remedies if the infringement was deliberate?
- Can the court order a party to recall infringing products? If so, is there a limitation in time?
-
VIII. Injunctions
- Is it possible to obtain a preliminary injunction in your jurisdiction? If so, what are the requirements?
- Is it possible to obtain a without notice injunction?
- How quickly can preliminary injunctions be obtained?
- Is it possible to appeal against a preliminary injunction and if so does this suspend the effect of the injunction?
- If a party is awarded a preliminary injunction are they liable to provide security?
- Are further proceedings on the merits required in order for the court to grant a final injunction?
- Is a cross-border injunction available and in what circumstances?
- Is an Anti-Suit-Injunction (ASI) available and in what circumstances?
jurisdiction
I. Standing
1. Who is entitled to sue for patent infringement?
Under the Portuguese Industrial Property Code (Código da Propriedade Industrial or CPI), the patent holder is the primary person entitled to bring an infringement action. In addition, exclusive licensees are generally recognised as having standing to sue for infringement, subject to the terms of the licence agreement. Non-exclusive licensees may also have standing if the licence contract so provides and/or if the patent holder consents or is joined. The CPI and general civil procedural rules govern standing in these cases.
2. Is it possible to join more than one party as a defendant?
Yes. Under general Portuguese civil procedural rules (Código de Processo Civil or CPC), it is possible to join multiple defendants in the same proceedings where the claims arise from the same facts or are connected. This allows, for example, a patent holder to sue a manufacturer and a distributor of the infringing product in the same action.
3. Is it possible to join suppliers or other third parties to the proceedings?
Yes. The CPC allows for the intervention of third parties (intervenção de terceiros), including suppliers or other parties in the distribution chain, through principal or accessory intervention, provided the procedural requirements are met.
4. Is there any time limit in which claims for patent infringement must be brought?
Patent infringement claims are subject to the general civil liability limitation period. Under Portuguese civil law (Código Civil or CC), the general limitation period for civil liability is three years from the date the injured party became aware of its right to compensation, subject to the ordinary twenty-year longstop period. Additionally, the CPI provides that nullity actions may be brought at any time during the life of the patent, while annulment actions are subject to specific time limits.
5. Is there a requirement to invoke all potentially infringed patents at once?
Portuguese procedural law does not impose a strict requirement to invoke all potentially infringed patents in a single action. A patent holder may bring separate proceedings for different patents. However, considerations of procedural economy and the risk of inconsistent decisions may favour consolidation of related claims.
II. Timing and Forum
6. In what court are patent litigation proceedings brought in your jurisdiction? Are infringement and validity decided in the same proceedings?
Patent infringement proceedings in Portugal are brought before the Intellectual Property Court (Tribunal da Propriedade Intelectual or TPI), which is a specialised first-instance court with extended territorial jurisdiction covering the entire national territory. Article 111 of the Judicial System Organisation Law (Lei No. 62/2013) assigns this court jurisdiction over actions whose cause of action concerns industrial property rights in any form, including patent matters. The same provision also gives it jurisdiction over nullity and annulment actions concerning patents, supplementary protection certificates, utility models, and semiconductor topographies. Infringement and validity can therefore be decided in the same proceedings, as the defendant in an infringement action may raise invalidity as a defence or counterclaim before the same court.
7. Does your country take part in the UPC?
Yes. Portugal approved the Agreement on a Unified Patent Court through Resolution of the Assembly of the Republic No. 108/2015 and ratified it by Presidential Decree No. 90/2015 of 6 August 2015. The UPC Agreement entered into force on 1 June 2023, and Portugal has a local division of the UPC, located in the same building as the Intellectual Property Court in Lisbon. The language of proceedings in the Portuguese local division is Portuguese, although English is also accepted. Notice No. 52/2024/1 confirmed the entry into force formalities.
8. Can a party apply for a declaration of non-infringement?
Yes. Under Portuguese law, a party may seek a declaratory judgment (ação declarativa de simples apreciação negativa) establishing that its activities do not infringe a patent. Such actions are brought before the Intellectual Property Court.
9. How long does it take for a claim to reach a first hearing?
There are no fixed statutory deadlines specific to patent cases. Based on general practice before the Intellectual Property Court, a case typically reaches a first hearing (preliminary hearing or audiência prévia) within approximately 12 to 18 months of filing. Patent cases, being technically complex, may take longer.
10. How long do trials last in patent cases until a first instance decision?
Patent cases at the Intellectual Property Court typically take approximately 18 to 30 months from filing to a first-instance decision, depending on complexity, the number of parties, and whether technical expert evidence is required.
11. Do the judges have technical expertise?
Judges at the Intellectual Property Court are generalist judges, not technical specialists. However, they may appoint technical experts (peritos) to assist with technical questions. The government has approved a regime of legal and technical-scientific advisory support for magistrates to strengthen judicial capacity.
12. Will the courts stay proceedings pending the outcome of a related opposition at the EPO?
There is no automatic stay of Portuguese proceedings pending the outcome of an EPO opposition. The court has discretion to stay proceedings if it considers that the EPO opposition outcome is likely to be decisive. In practice, Portuguese courts have tended to proceed with cases without awaiting EPO decisions, particularly in preliminary injunction proceedings, where the registered patent is presumed valid.
13. Can a party file an action for nullification of a patent without being sued for patent infringement?
Yes. Under the CPI, nullity and annulment actions may be brought independently before the Intellectual Property Court without the need for a prior infringement action. Nullity actions may be brought at any time, and one or more claims may be declared null; however, partial nullity of a single claim is not permitted.
14. Can a party file an action for a FRAND license or a compulsory license?
The CPI provides for compulsory licences (licenças obrigatórias) in specific circumstances, such as non-working of the patent, dependent patents, or reasons of public interest. Compulsory licence requests may be filed before the Intellectual Property Court or the Portuguese Industrial Property Office (Instituto Nacional da Propriedade Industrial or INPI), depending on the ground invoked. FRAND licenses are not regulated under Portuguese law.
15. Can a party invoke the FRAND defence in patent infringement proceedings?
A defendant in patent infringement proceedings involving a standard-essential patent (SEP) may invoke the FRAND defence, arguing that the patent holder has failed to offer a licence on fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory terms. While the CPI does not contain express provisions on FRAND, EU case law (notably the CJEU's Huawei v. ZTE framework) applies in Portugal.
III. Evidence
16. Are expert witnesses used by parties to a patent infringement case? Can a party bring its own expert witnesses or do expert witnesses need to be appointed by the court?
Yes. Expert witnesses (peritos) are commonly used in patent cases in Portugal. Under the CPC, the court may appoint experts, and parties may also present their own expert evidence (pareceres técnicos). Court-appointed experts are the primary mechanism, but party-appointed experts are permitted and frequently used in practice.
17. Do the courts allow disclosure/discovery?
Portuguese civil procedure does not follow common-law-style discovery. However, a party may request the court to order the opposing party or third parties to produce specific, identified documents under Articles 429 and 432 of the CPC. The court plays an active role in deciding whether and to what extent disclosure is ordered, applying principles of proportionality and necessity. Additionally, the CPI's provisions transposing the Enforcement Directive (2004/48/EC) provide for a right to information (direito de informação), allowing the court to order the infringer to provide information on the origin and distribution networks of infringing goods.
18. Are preliminary discovery or seizure of evidence/ documents available?
Yes. Portuguese law provides for the preservation of evidence (produção antecipada de prova) and for seizure of evidence measures. Under the CPI, the court may order the inspection and seizure of goods, materials, and documents related to the alleged infringement as an interim measure. These provisions reflect the transposition of Directive 2004/48/EC.
IV. Appeals
19. What are the possible routes for appeal?
First-instance decisions from the Intellectual Property Court are appealed to the Lisbon Court of Appeal (Tribunal da Relação de Lisboa), specifically to its Section for Intellectual Property and Competition, Regulation and Supervision (Secção da Propriedade Intelectual e da Concorrência, Regulação e Supervisão). A further appeal (revista) may lie to the Supreme Court of Justice (Supremo Tribunal de Justiça) on questions of law, subject to admissibility requirements.
20. On what grounds can an appeal be brought?
An appeal to the Lisbon Court of Appeal (apelação) may challenge the first-instance decision on both questions of fact and law. An appeal to the Supreme Court (revista) is limited to questions of law and is subject to specific admissibility criteria, including the value of the case exceeding a statutory threshold.
21. What is an approximate timescale for the first/ second appeal?
An appeal to the Lisbon Court of Appeal typically takes approximately 12 to 24 months. A further appeal to the Supreme Court, where admissible, may take an additional 12 to 18 months.
22. Is the first instance decision suspended while an appeal is pending?
Under general Portuguese procedural rules, an appeal (apelação) normally has suspensive effect when the first-instance decision ordered payment or performance. However, the rules on suspensive versus devolutive effect depend on the nature of the decision. In patent cases, if the first-instance decision grants an injunction, the appeal may or may not suspend the injunction depending on the specific circumstances and any request by the parties.
V. Costs
23. What would be the estimated legal costs of patent litigation proceedings for a first instance decision?
The estimated legal costs for a first-instance patent case in Portugal vary considerably depending on complexity, but they are generally lower than in many other European jurisdictions. Court fees (taxa de justiça) are calculated based on the value of the action. Legal fees (attorney costs) for a first-instance patent case may range approximately from €50,000 to €200,000, though simpler cases can cost less and highly complex pharmaceutical patent disputes may cost more.
24. What would be the estimated legal costs of patent litigation proceedings for an appeal?
Appeal costs are generally lower than first-instance costs. Legal fees for an appeal might range approximately from €20,000 to €80,000, with additional court fees. These figures are approximate and depend on the complexity of the case.
25. Are litigation costs recoverable? If so, is there a limitation?
Yes. Under Portuguese procedural law, the successful party is generally entitled to recover court fees (custas de parte) from the losing party. However, the recovery of legal fees (attorney costs) is limited, as Portuguese law does not typically allow full recovery of attorney fees. The recoverable amounts are determined according to statutory scales and are usually lower than the actual costs incurred.
VI. Alternative Dispute Resolution
26. What are the options for alternative dispute resolution in your jurisdiction? Are these commonly used?
Portugal provides for arbitration and mediation as alternative dispute resolution mechanisms for IP disputes. The Portuguese Voluntary Arbitration Law (Lei No. 63/2011) permits parties to submit patent disputes to arbitration if the subject matter is available (disponível). Mediation is also available under the Mediation Law (Lei No. 29/2013). In practice, ADR is not yet commonly used in patent disputes in Portugal, where most cases are litigated before the Intellectual Property Court.
27. Does the court require that parties consider these options at any stage in proceedings?
There is no mandatory ADR requirement in patent proceedings. However, during the preliminary hearing (audiência prévia), the judge may encourage the parties to reach a settlement. The CPC also provides for judicial mediation (mediação judicial), which the court may suggest but cannot impose.
VII. Remedies
28. What remedies are available for patent infringement? Does your jurisdiction provide for automatic injunctions?
The CPI provides a range of remedies for patent infringement, including injunctions (cessation of the infringing activity), damages, seizure and destruction of infringing goods, and publication of the judgment. Portugal does not provide for strictly automatic injunctions; however, injunctions are the standard remedy for proven patent infringement, and courts routinely grant them upon a finding of infringement. The presumption of validity of a registered patent supports the grant of injunctive relief.
29. On what basis are damages calculated?
Damages for patent infringement under the CPI may be calculated on the basis of: (a) the actual damage suffered by the patent holder, including lost profits; (b) the profits made by the infringer attributable to the infringement; or (c) a reasonable royalty that would have been due had the infringer obtained a licence. When a reasonable royalty approach is used, the rate is typically assessed by reference to comparable licence agreements in the relevant industry and the specific circumstances of the case.
30. Does the court order an enquiry into damages?
Portuguese courts may determine damages either within the main proceedings or defer the quantification of damages to a subsequent phase (liquidação de sentença) if the exact amount cannot be determined at the time of the judgment on the merits. This is functionally similar to an enquiry into damages.
31. Is it possible to obtain additional remedies if the infringement was deliberate?
Yes. Under the CPI, the court may consider the deliberate nature of the infringement when assessing damages, potentially resulting in higher damages awards. Wilful infringement may also support claims for moral damages and may influence the court's decision regarding ancillary remedies such as publication of the judgment.
32. Can the court order a party to recall infringing products? If so, is there a limitation in time?
Yes. The court may order the recall and destruction of infringing products and of materials and implements predominantly used in their creation, in accordance with the CPI provisions transposing the Enforcement Directive. There is no specific statutory time limit on the order for recall, but it must be proportionate. The recall is typically ordered as part of the final judgment.
VIII. Injunctions
33. Is it possible to obtain a preliminary injunction in your jurisdiction? If so, what are the requirements?
Yes. Preliminary injunctions (providências cautelares) are available in patent cases in Portugal. The requirements generally include: (a) the applicant must demonstrate a fumus boni juris (likelihood that the right exists and is being infringed); (b) the applicant must show a periculum in mora (risk of serious and irreparable harm if the injunction is not granted); and (c) the relief sought must be proportionate. The registered patent benefits from a presumption of validity, which supports the fumus boni juris requirement.
34. Is it possible to obtain a without notice injunction?
Yes. Under the CPC, the court may grant a preliminary injunction without hearing the opposing party (inaudita altera parte) in cases of exceptional urgency or where prior notice could render the measure ineffective. This possibility exists in patent cases, although it is used sparingly.
35. How quickly can preliminary injunctions be obtained?
Preliminary injunctions can typically be obtained within a few weeks to a few months. In cases of extreme urgency, inaudita altera parte orders may be obtained within days. The timeline depends on the court's calendar and the complexity of the matter.
36. Is it possible to appeal against a preliminary injunction and if so does this suspend the effect of the injunction?
Yes. A preliminary injunction may be appealed to the Lisbon Court of Appeal. As a general rule, the appeal against a preliminary injunction does not suspend its effect — the injunction remains in force during the appeal, unless the appellate court specifically orders otherwise.
37. If a party is awarded a preliminary injunction are they liable to provide security?
The court may, in its discretion, require the applicant to provide security (caução) as a condition for granting the preliminary injunction. This serves to protect the respondent in the event that the injunction is later found to have been unjustified. Whether security is required depends on the circumstances of the case.
38. Are further proceedings on the merits required in order for the court to grant a final injunction?
Yes. A preliminary injunction is a provisional measure. The applicant must bring main proceedings on the merits (ação principal) in order to obtain a final injunction. Under the CPC, the applicant must file the main action within 30 days of the granting of the preliminary injunction (if it was not already pending), failing which the preliminary injunction lapses.
39. Is a cross-border injunction available and in what circumstances?
Cross-border injunctions are not a standard feature of Portuguese patent law, which is territorial in nature. However, under EU regulations (notably the Brussels I Regulation Recast), a Portuguese court may grant provisional measures with effects limited to Portugal even where the main proceedings are in another Member State. For European patents with unitary effect, the UPC (including its Portuguese local division) has jurisdiction that can lead to injunctions with cross-border effect within the participating Member States.
40. Is an Anti-Suit-Injunction (ASI) available and in what circumstances?
Anti-suit injunctions are not a recognised instrument in Portuguese procedural law. Portuguese courts, operating within the continental European civil law tradition, do not issue orders restraining parties from pursuing proceedings in other jurisdictions.