Key contacts
-
I. Standing
- Who is entitled to sue for patent infringement?
- Is it possible to join more than one party as a defendant?
- Is it possible to join suppliers or other third parties to the proceedings?
- Is there any time limit in which claims for patent infringement must be brought?
- Is there a requirement to invoke all potentially infringed patents at once?
-
II. Timing and Forum
- In what court are patent litigation proceedings brought in your jurisdiction? Are infringement and validity decided in the same proceedings?
- Does your country take part in the UPC?
- Can a party apply for a declaration of non-infringement?
- How long does it take for a claim to reach a first hearing?
- How long do trials last in patent cases until a first instance decision?
- Do the judges have technical expertise?
- Will the courts stay proceedings pending the outcome of a related opposition at the EPO?
- Can a party file an action for nullification of a patent without being sued for patent infringement?
- Can a party file an action for a FRAND license or a compulsory license?
- Can a party invoke the FRAND defence in patent infringement proceedings? What will be the consequence of a successful FRAND defence? Do the courts determine a (global) FRAND rate?
-
III. Evidence
- Are expert witnesses used by parties to a patent infringement case? Can a party bring its own expert witnesses or do expert witnesses need to be appointed by the court?
- Do the courts allow disclosure/discovery? If yes, what documents does a party have to disclose? Does the court play an active role in deciding the extent of the disclosure exercise?
- Are preliminary discovery or seizure of evidence/ documents available?
- IV. Appeals
- V. Costs
- VI. Alternative Dispute Resolution
-
VII Remedies
- What remedies are available for patent infringement? Does your jurisdiction provide for automatic injunctions in case of patent infringement?
- On what basis are damages calculated? If damages are based on a reasonable royalty, how is this rate usually calculated?
- Does the court order an enquiry into damages (separate proceedings to determine the level of damages payable)?
- Is it possible to obtain additional remedies if the infringement was deliberate?
- Can the court order a party to recall infringing products? If so, is there a limitation in time?
-
VIII Injunctions
- Is it possible to obtain a preliminary injunction in your jurisdiction? If so, what are the requirements?
- Is it possible to obtain a without notice injunction?
- How quickly can preliminary injunctions be obtained?
- Is it possible to appeal against a preliminary injunction and if so does this suspend the effect of the injunction?
- If a party is awarded a preliminary injunction are they liable to provide security?
- Are further proceedings on the merits required in order for the court to grant a final injunction?
- Is a cross-border injunction available and in what circumstances?
- Is an Anti-Suit-Injunction (ASI) available and in what circumstances?
jurisdiction
I. Standing
1.Who is entitled to sue for patent infringement?
The owner and usufructuary of a patent is entitled to bring patent infringement proceedings. 1 Where a patent is jointly owned, each co-owner may initiate proceedings but only with the consent of the other co-owner(s) or, failing such consent, with the authorization of the court. 2
An exclusive licensee, unless otherwise provided, and the holder of a compulsory license may bring infringement proceedings if, after being given notice, the patent owner or usufructuary fails to do so. 3
Any licensee may intervene in infringement proceedings brought by the patent owner or usufructuary in order to seek compensation for its own loss. 4
2. Is it possible to join more than one party as a defendant?
Yes, any number of parties may be joined as defendants.
3. Is it possible to join suppliers or other third parties to the proceedings?
Yes, suppliers or other third parties may be joined.
Belgian law also permits the court to issue injunctions against intermediaries whose services are used by a third party to infringe a patent 5 .
The court may also order the disclosure of information regarding an infringement from persons who have been found to possess infringing goods on a commercial scale, to use infringing services on a commercial scale or to provide, on a commercial scale, services used in infringing activities. 6
4. Is there any time limit in which claims for patent infringement must be brought?
Patent infringement claims are subject to a five-year limitation period running from the date on which the alleged act of infringement was committed. 7
Infringement proceedings may be commenced only after the patent has been made available to the public and only in respect of infringing acts committed from that date. 8
5. Is there a requirement to invoke all potentially infringed patents at once?
No. Separate proceedings may be brought in respect of different patents.
Where the separate actions are closely connected, the court may join them in order to avoid inconsistent decisions.
In addition, during pending proceedings, a claim may be extended or amended in the submissions, provided that the amended claim is based on a fact or act referred to in the summons, even if its legal qualification is different, and provided that the defendant has an opportunity to respond. 9
II. Timing and Forum
6. In what court are patent litigation proceedings brought in your jurisdiction? Are infringement and validity decided in the same proceedings?
Patent disputes fall within the exclusive jurisdiction of the Brussels Enterprise Court (French or Dutch speaking), irrespective of the parties’ status as undertakings and regardless of the amount in dispute (without prejudice to the jurisdiction of the Unified Patent Court and arbitration courts where applicable). 10
Infringement and validity may be decided in the same proceedings. In practice, patent invalidity is frequently challenged by way of defence or counterclaim in infringement actions, and the court addresses both infringement and validity in a single judgment.
7. Does your country take part in the UPC?
Yes, Belgium takes part in the UPC system and ratified the UPC Agreement in 2014.
A UPC local division is established in Brussels.
8. Can a party apply for a declaration of non-infringement?
Yes, a declaration of non-infringement may be sought by any person having a legitimate interest in bringing the claim. 11 The claimant must demonstrate that its rights are subject to a serious threat (e.g. the existence of a genuine dispute or a sufficiently serious threat that its activities may be alleged to infringe the patent). The court will not allow a claim that is essentially seeking an advisory opinion in the absence of a concrete and current interest.
9. How long does it take for a claim to reach a first hearing?
It generally takes between six months to one year, or longer, for a claim to reach a hearing, depending on the workload of the court, the timetable and the number of submission rounds.
10. How long do trials last in patent cases until a first instance decision?
Hearings in patent cases typically last a few hours, although complex cases may require multiple hearing sessions.
It depends on the type of action (cease and desist action or proceedings on the merits), complexity of the case, the number of parties, the number of written submissions, the volume of evidence and expert material, etc.
Following the hearing, the court must in principle render a decision within one month. In practice, however, decisions are rendered within one to three months after the hearing.
11. Do the judges have technical expertise?
No. Belgian judges do not generally have a technical expertise. However, the concentration of patent litigation before specific chambers of the Brussels Enterprise Court and Court of Appeal has led to an increasing degree of specialisation of the judges.
12. Will the courts stay proceedings pending the outcome of a related opposition at the EPO?
There is no automatic stay of patent proceedings pending the outcome of an EPO opposition. The court has discretion to stay the proceedings (e.g. where an EPO decision is expected within a relatively short timeframe and is likely to be decisive for the issues before the court).
13. Can a party file an action for nullification of a patent without being sued for patent infringement?
Yes, a party may file an action for revocation (nullity) of a patent without first being sued for patent infringement, provided that it has an interest in seeking revocation of the patent.
14. Can a party file an action for a FRAND license or a compulsory license?
Yes, a party can file such actions.
Yes, such actions are available.
A party may bring an action seeking a determination of FRAND terms or the grant of a licence on FRAND terms for standard-essential patents (SEPs).
A compulsory license may be sought in limited circumstances, including where a patented invention is not sufficiently exploited, where exploitation of a later patent depends on an earlier patent and in certain public health situations. Applications for compulsory licenses are subject to specific statutory procedures and the involvement of the competent public authorities 12 .
15. Can a party invoke the FRAND defence in patent infringement proceedings? What will be the consequence of a successful FRAND defence? Do the courts determine a (global) FRAND rate?
A party may invoke the FRAND defence in patent infringement proceedings. Belgian case law on FRAND licenses is very limited.
III. Evidence
16. Are expert witnesses used by parties to a patent infringement case? Can a party bring its own expert witnesses or do expert witnesses need to be appointed by the court?
Yes, expert witnesses may be used by the parties. Parties may rely on their own experts.
The court may also appoint an expert to investigate and advise the court on technical issues, either on a party’s request or of its own initiative. 13 The expert will submit a written report containing his observations. 14 The judge may hear the expert at the trial. 15
Judges are not bound by expert reports.
17. Do the courts allow disclosure/discovery? If yes, what documents does a party have to disclose? Does the court play an active role in deciding the extent of the disclosure exercise?
There is no specific disclosure / discovery procedure in Belgium. Parties are free to produce the evidence supporting their allegations.
However, where there is serious and specific evidence that a party or third party holds a document evidencing a relevant fact, the judge may order that document or a certified copy to be produced in the proceedings. 16
18. Are preliminary discovery or seizure of evidence/ documents available?
Yes. The president of the Enterprise Court may, on an ex parte application by a person who is entitled to bring infringement proceedings, grant a descriptive seizure order (saisie decription/beslag inzake namaak), whereby an expert is appointed in order to describe the origin, destination and extent of the alleged infringement. 17 The judge may also order seizure of the infringing goods. 18 The description and seizure take place at the premises of the alleged infringer, after which the expert files a report with the Court.
Proceedings on the merits should then be initiated within the applicable period, failing which the contents of the report may not be relied on. 19
IV. Appeals
19. What are the possible routes for appeal in your jurisdiction?
A first instance decision may be appealed before the Brussels court of appeal. The appeal has to be filed within one month from service of the first instance decision. 20
A court of appeal’s decision may then be appealed before the Supreme Court, within three months from service of the court of appeal’s decision. 21
20. On what grounds can an appeal be brought?
All aspects of the first instance judgment may be challenged before the Brussels court of appeal. 22
A further appeal to the Supreme Court is limited to legal issues.
21. What is an approximate timescale for the first/ second appeal?
The first appeal in an accelerated procedure on the merits takes about one year. An appeal in an ordinary procedure may take several years.
A Supreme Court appeal takes around one year.
22. Is the first instance decision suspended while an appeal is pending?
No. The first instance decision is not suspended while an appeal is pending. The convicted party must comply with the first instance decision, notwithstanding the appeal.
V. Costs
23. What would be the estimated legal costs of patent litigation proceedings for a first instance decision?
This depends on various factors (such as lawyer’s fees, complexity of the case, the number of submissions to be filed, the involvement of technical experts, the need to translate documents, etc.). Costs are typically in the range of EUR 50,000 to EUR 200,000.
24. What would be the estimated legal costs of patent litigation proceedings for an appeal?
Again, this depends on complexity, the nature and number of appellate arguments, lawyer’s fees etc.). Costs are usually in the range of EUR 50,000 to EUR 200,000.
25. Are litigation costs recoverable? If so, is there a limitation?
Yes, but only to a limited extent. The court will order the losing party to pay a “procedural indemnity” (indemnité de procedure/rechtsplegingsvergoeding), which is intended to contribute to the successful party’s legal representation costs. The amount is determined by law on the basis of the value of the claim. The successful party cannot recover its actual legal fees beyond that statutory indemnity. 23
VI. Alternative Dispute Resolution
26. What are the options for alternative dispute resolution in your jurisdiction? Are these commonly used?
The main ADR routes available in Belgium are negotiation, conciliation, mediation and arbitration.
Negotiation is a discussion between the parties. This type of proceedings can be carried out with or without a lawyer, and may therefore be free of charge.
Conciliation is a voluntary and totally free procedure. All exchanges between the parties are confidential, and the conciliating judge may, after hearing the parties and their lawyers, suggest solutions that the parties can agree upon. If an agreement is reached, the terms of the agreement are recorded and become binding upon the parties. 24
Mediation is a confidential, structured process of voluntary consultation between parties in conflict, conducted with the assistance of an independent, neutral and impartial third party who facilitates communication and attempts to lead the parties to work out a solution themselves. 25 Mediation involves costs: lawyers’ and mediator’s fees.
Disputes may also be brought in front of arbitral courts. 26 Arbitration proceedings are faster and more specialised but also more expensive than proceedings before the judicial courts.
These options are not commonly used in Belgium.
27. Does the court require that parties consider these options at any stage in proceedings?
The court may ask the parties to consider these options at any stage of the proceedings.
VII Remedies
28. What remedies are available for patent infringement? Does your jurisdiction provide for automatic injunctions in case of patent infringement?
The remedies available in patent infringement cases are:
- injunctive relief 27 ;
- award of damages 28 ;
- publication or display of the judgement or a summary thereof 29 ;
- recall, removal or destruction of the infringing goods and, where appropriate, of the materials and tools used in their creation or manufacture, at the expense of the infringer 30 ; and/or
- the disclosure of information regarding the origin and distribution networks of the infringing goods or services 31 .
29. On what basis are damages calculated? If damages are based on a reasonable royalty, how is this rate usually calculated?
Damages must compensate the actual prejudice suffered by the claimant as a result of the infringement. 32
Belgian law does not prescribe a single method for quantifying damages.
The claimant must prove the extent of damage suffered, including lost profits (i.e. the profits that the patent owner would have made if the infringement had not occurred) and actual losses incurred (including enforcement costs).
Where the claimant exploits the patented invention itself, damages may be assessed by reference to the profits that would have been earned in the absence of the infringement (e.g. margins). Where the claimant does not exploit the invention, damages are often assessed by reference to a reasonable royalty or license fee that would have been payable for lawful use of the patented invention.
Where damages cannot be determined in any other way, the court may award a lump sum. 33
The judge may, by way of damages, order delivery up of the infringing goods and materials and tools used in their creation or manufacture. Where the infringement was committed in bad faith, the court may also order the assignment to the claimant of all or part of the profits realized through the infringement 34 and / or the confiscation of the infringing goods for the claimant’s benefit. 35
30. Does the court order an enquiry into damages (separate proceedings to determine the level of damages payable)?
Belgian law does not provide for separate proceedings specifically dedicated to the assessment of damages.
However, ex parte descriptive seizure proceedings (procedure de saisie-description) may be used to obtain evidence regarding the existence, origin and extent of the infringement. 36
In addition, as part of proceedings on the merits, the production of specific information relevant to the infringement and the quantification of damages may be sought. 37
The court may also appoint an expert to provide an opinion on technical, accounting or economic issues relevant to the assessment of damages.
31. Is it possible to obtain additional remedies if the infringement was deliberate?
Yes. Where the infringement has been committed in bad faith, the judge may order the assignment to the claimant of all or part of the profits realized by the infringer as a result of the infringement and/or the confiscation of the infringing goods for the claimant’s benefit. 38
If the goods, materials or tools are no longer in the defendant’s possession, the judge may order payment of a sum corresponding to the proceeds received for them. Confiscation absorbs damages up to the value of the confiscation. 39
32. Can the court order a party to recall infringing products? If so, is there a limitation in time?
Yes. The court may order a recall, removal or destruction of the infringing goods as well as, where appropriate, of the materials and tools used in their creation or manufacture, at the infringer’s expense. 40
There is no specific limitation in time provided by the law.
In assessing a request for such measure, account will be taken of the proportionality between the seriousness of the infringement and the corrective measure ordered, as well as of the interests of third parties. 41
VIII Injunctions
33. Is it possible to obtain a preliminary injunction in your jurisdiction? If so, what are the requirements?
Yes. A claimant may seek provisional measures in summary proceedings before the president of the Brussels Enterprise Court. 42 To obtain provisional relief, the claimant must prove urgency, i.e. the need to obtain a quick decision in order to avoid serious harm that would be difficult to remedy, as well as a prima facie valid right and infringement.
Provisional measures may also be sought during proceedings on the merits in order to provisionally settle the parties’ situation pending a final decision, where waiting for a judgment on the merits would be inappropriate. 43
In addition to preliminary injunctions, final injunctions are available and may be granted in accelerated proceedings on the merits (procédure comme en référé). In that case, the claimant must demonstrate that the patent is valid and infringed. No urgency requirement applies. 44
34. Is it possible to obtain a without notice injunction?
Yes, ex parte preliminary injunctions are available, but only in cases of absolute necessity (in addition to a prima facie valid right and infringement). 45
Such measures are not frequently granted in practice.
35. How quickly can preliminary injunctions be obtained?
Preliminary injunctions can be obtained within one to six months.
Ex parte preliminary injunctions may even be obtained within a few days.
Final injunctions are usually obtained within six to twelve months.
36. Is it possible to appeal against a preliminary injunction and if so does this suspend the effect of the injunction?
It is possible to appeal against a preliminary injunction.
An appeal does not suspend the effect of the injunction, unless the judge decides otherwise. 46
37. If a party is awarded a preliminary injunction are they liable to provide security?
The judge may make the grant of the injunction conditional upon the provision of a security or guarantee intended to compensate the defendant for any harm resulting from the injunction that is later withdrawn or considered to be unfounded. 47 In practice, however, such security is only rarely required.
The claimant enforces an injunction at its own risk and may be liable for the harm suffered by the defendant if the injunction is subsequently lifted.
38. Are further proceedings on the merits required in order for the court to grant a final injunction?
Although preliminary injunctions are provisional in nature, they may remain effective for an indefinite period if no proceedings on the merits are subsequently introduced and the injunction is not lifted or varied.
39. Is a cross-border injunction available and in what circumstances?
Yes, cross-border injunctions are available where the Belgian courts have international jurisdiction over the dispute.
40. Is an Anti-Suit-Injunction (ASI) available and in what circumstances?
No, anti-suit-injunctions are not available in Belgium.