International Patent Litigation in Slovakia
Key contacts
-
I. Standing
- Who is entitled to sue for patent infringement?
- Is it possible to join more than one party as a defendant?
- Is it possible to join suppliers or other third parties to the proceedings?
- Is there any time limit in which claims for patent infringement must be brought?
- Is there a requirement to invoke all potentially infringed patents at once?
-
II. Timing and Forum
- In what court are patent litigation proceedings brought in your jurisdiction? Are infringement and validity decided in the same proceedings?
- Does your country take part in the UPC?
- Can a party apply for a declaration of non-infringement?
- How long does it take for a claim to reach a first hearing?
- How long do trials last in patent cases until a first instance decision?
- Do the judges have technical expertise?
- Will the courts stay proceedings pending the outcome of a related opposition at the EPO?
- Can a party file an action for nullification of a patent without being sued for patent infringement?
- Can a party file an action for a FRAND license or a compulsory license?
- Can a party invoke the FRAND defence in patent infringement proceedings? What will be the consequence of a successful FRAND defence? Do the courts determine a (global) FRAND rate?
-
III. Evidence
- Are expert witnesses used by parties to a patent infringement case? Can a party bring its own expert witnesses or do expert witnesses need to be appointed by the court?
- Do the courts allow disclosure/discovery? If yes, what documents does a party have to disclose? Does the court play an active role in deciding the extent of the disclosure exercise?
- Are preliminary discovery or seizure of evidence/ documents available?
- IV. Appeals
- V. Costs
- VI. Alternative Dispute Resolution
-
VII. Remedies
- What remedies are available for patent infringement? Does your jurisdiction provide for automatic injunctions in case of patent infringement?
- On what basis are damages calculated? If damages are based on a reasonable royalty, how is this rate usually calculated?
- Does the court order an enquiry into damages (separate proceedings to determine the level of damages payable)?
- Is it possible to obtain additional remedies if the infringement was deliberate?
- Can the court order a party to recall infringing products? If so, is there a limitation in time?
-
VIII. Injunctions
- Is it possible to obtain a preliminary injunction in your jurisdiction? If so, what are the requirements?
- Is it possible to obtain a without notice injunction?
- How quickly can preliminary injunctions be obtained?
- Is it possible to appeal against a preliminary injunction and if so does this suspend the effect of the injunction?
- If a party is awarded a preliminary injunction are they liable to provide security?
- Are further proceedings on the merits required in order for the court to grant a final injunction?
- Is a cross-border injunction available and in what circumstances?
- Is an Anti-Suit-Injunction (ASI) available and in what circumstances?
jurisdiction
I. Standing
1.Who is entitled to sue for patent infringement?
Patent holders and their licensees have the right to bring patent infringement claims before Slovak courts.
As a rule, a licensee must obtain the patent owner’s approval to initiate such proceedings. However, if the patent owner fails to act within a reasonable time after being informed by the licensee of an actual or potential infringement, an exclusive licensee is entitled to commence legal action without that approval.
Under Slovak law, professional associations do not have standing to independently pursue patent infringement claims on behalf of patent proprietors.
2. Is it possible to join more than one party as a defendant?
The claimant is responsible for identifying the defendant or defendants, and more than one party may be held liable.
The court may, however, decide to divide the case into separate proceedings for each defendant, particularly where the claims rely on different legal grounds in relation to each of them.
In the course of the proceedings, the claimant also has the option to apply for the inclusion of an additional party as a defendant. Whether such a request is granted is subject to the court’s discretion.
3. Is it possible to join suppliers or other third parties to the proceedings?
Yes. Third parties with a vested interest in the outcome of the case may participate in the proceedings as indirect interveners. Such participation can be initiated either by the third party itself or upon a motion submitted to the court by one of the existing parties. The decision on whether to permit this participation ultimately rests with the court.
4. Is there any time limit in which claims for patent infringement must be brought?
Yes. A patent infringement claim must be filed within the applicable limitation period. The claimant is required to act within three years from the date on which it became aware of the infringement. In any event, the claim must be brought no later than five years from the occurrence of the infringing act. Where the infringement was intentional, this long-stop period is extended to ten years from the time the infringement took place. These limitation periods reflect the general rules of Slovak civil law, as the Patent Act does not prescribe patent-specific limitation periods.
5. Is there a requirement to invoke all potentially infringed patents at once?
No. The claimant has the discretion to define the extent of the alleged infringement.
II. Timing and Forum
6. In what court are patent litigation proceedings brought in your jurisdiction? Are infringement and validity decided in the same proceedings?
Under Slovak law, a clear distinction is drawn between infringement proceedings and validity proceedings. Patent infringement cases fall within the jurisdiction of the civil courts, whereas challenges to the validity of a patent are handled separately in administrative proceedings before the Industrial Property Office of the Slovak Republic (ÚPV SR), with the possibility of subsequent review by the administrative courts.
Jurisdiction over infringement claims lies exclusively with the District Court Banská Bystrica, whose territorial jurisdiction extends to the whole of the Slovak Republic for industrial-property disputes..
In contrast, applications for patent invalidity must be filed with the ÚPV SR. Decisions issued by the Office may be appealed to its Head, and any final decision can then be further contested before the administrative courts. The following section relating to Slovakia is limited to civil law aspects only.
7. Does your country take part in the UPC?
No.
8. Can a party apply for a declaration of non-infringement?
Yes. A person with a legitimate interest in establishing non‑infringement may pursue two possible routes. They may either initiate proceedings before the District Court Banská Bystrica or submit a request to the Industrial Property Office of the Slovak Republic (ÚPV SR).
Proceedings before the District Court Banská Bystrica are admissible only where the claimant can demonstrate an urgent legal interest in obtaining a declaration of non‑infringement. The court proceedings are rarely pursued in practice, as courts have so far refused to consider such actions substantively, rejecting them on the grounds that the claimant failed to demonstrate an urgent legal interest. As a result, despite the theoretical availability of this remedy, declaratory proceedings for non-infringement before the civil courts are of limited practical utility in Slovakia at present.
Alternatively, a petition may be filed with the ÚPV SR where the applicant seeks clarification as to whether a specific product or solution falls within the scope of a patent’s protection.
9. How long does it take for a claim to reach a first hearing?
In IP infringement cases, the first hearing is typically scheduled within approximately nine to twelve months. This timeframe is indicative only, as the actual duration may differ depending on factors such as the complexity of the matter and the court’s workload.
10. How long do trials last in patent cases until a first instance decision?
The duration of patent proceedings is not fixed and varies depending on the circumstances of each case, including its complexity, the conduct of the parties, and the workload of the presiding judge. In practice, a first instance judgment is typically issued within approximately 18 to 24 months from the initiation of the action.
11. Do the judges have technical expertise?
No. There is a frequent observation that judges may not always possess specialised technical expertise.
12. Will the courts stay proceedings pending the outcome of a related opposition at the EPO?
The court is not required to suspend its proceedings while a related opposition is ongoing before the European Patent Office (EPO). However, it may choose to do so where another proceeding is addressing an issue that could influence its determination. Any decision to stay the proceedings is left to the court’s discretion and is made with regard to the specific circumstances of the case.
13. Can a party file an action for nullification of a patent without being sued for patent infringement?
Yes. Requests for patent nullification are submitted to the Industrial Property Office of the Slovak Republic (ÚPV SR) within the framework of administrative proceedings. These proceedings operate independently and are neither linked to nor contingent upon any parallel judicial processes.
14. Can a party file an action for a FRAND license or a compulsory license?
No, in relation to FRAND licences.
By contrast, compulsory licences are treated differently. An application for such a licence may be submitted to the Industrial Property Office of the Slovak Republic (ÚPV SR), which examines and decides on the request in administrative proceedings carried out under the Slovak Patent Act.
15. Can a party invoke the FRAND defence in patent infringement proceedings? What will be the consequence of a successful FRAND defence? Do the courts determine a (global) FRAND rate?
There is no specific Slovak legislation addressing the FRAND defence in the context of patent infringement proceedings, and there is no established domestic case law on the subject. However, as Slovakia is a Member State of the European Union, the principles established by the Court of Justice of the European Union in Case C-170/13 (Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd v ZTE Corp.) are applicable. Under the Huawei/ZTE framework, a holder of a standard-essential patent (SEP) that has given a FRAND commitment to a standard-setting organisation is obliged, before seeking injunctive relief, to (i) alert the alleged infringer to the infringement, specifying the patent and the manner in which it has been infringed, and (ii) present a written offer of a licence on fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory terms. If the patent holder fails to comply with these obligations, the alleged infringer may raise the FRAND defence, the consequence of which would be the denial of injunctive relief.
Slovak courts have not yet been called upon to determine a FRAND rate, and there is no established domestic practice in this regard.
III. Evidence
16. Are expert witnesses used by parties to a patent infringement case? Can a party bring its own expert witnesses or do expert witnesses need to be appointed by the court?
Yes. Expert evidence is frequently relied upon in patent infringement cases. In situations involving technical or scientific matters requiring specialised knowledge, the court may appoint an expert or otherwise obtain an expert opinion. Such opinions are generally provided in written form, although the expert may also be examined at a hearing if necessary.
In addition, the parties are entitled to submit their own expert reports. Where a private expert opinion complies with the statutory requirements—including confirmation that the expert is aware of the consequences of deliberately providing an incorrect opinion—it carries the same evidentiary weight as an opinion issued by a court-appointed expert.
17. Do the courts allow disclosure/discovery? If yes, what documents does a party have to disclose? Does the court play an active role in deciding the extent of the disclosure exercise?
No. Slovak legislation does not provide for a disclosure or discovery mechanism comparable to that found in common law systems.
As a general rule, each party determines which documents and information it chooses to present to the court. If the judge considers that essential evidence or information is missing, the relevant party may be requested to supplement the record and will be warned of the potential consequences of failing to do so.
Furthermore, the court has the authority to order a person in possession of a specific document to produce it for the purposes of the proceedings. Non-compliance with such an order may result in the imposition of financial penalties.
18. Are preliminary discovery or seizure of evidence/ documents available?
Preliminary discovery is not available, as Slovak law does not provide for a disclosure or discovery regime comparable to that used in common law jurisdictions.
However, provisional measures aimed at securing evidence or documents can be granted. For such measures to be ordered, the claimant must present sufficient evidence indicating patent infringement. The court may also require the claimant to lodge a security, the amount and deadline for payment of which are determined at the court’s discretion.
IV. Appeals
19. What are the possible routes for appeal in your jurisdiction?
A party to patent infringement proceedings has the right to challenge a decision of the District Court Banská Bystrica by lodging an appeal. Jurisdiction over such appeals lies with the Regional Court in Banská Bystrica. In certain circumstances, it is also possible to pursue an extraordinary appeal (dovolanie) against the Regional Court’s ruling before the Supreme Court of the Slovak Republic.
20. On what grounds can an appeal be brought?
An appeal may be lodged against a decision issued by the District Court Banská Bystrica where:
- the procedural requirements were not met,
- the court, through incorrect procedural conduct, prevented a party from exercising its procedural rights to such an extent that the right to a fair trial was violated,
- the case was decided by a disqualified judge or by a court composed in an improper manner,
- the proceedings are affected by another defect that could have resulted in an incorrect decision on the merits,
- the court of first instance failed to carry out the evidence proposed, which was necessary to establish the decisive facts,
- the court of first instance, on the basis of the evidence taken, reached incorrect findings of fact,
- the established facts cannot be upheld because further means of procedural defence or attack are available but were not relied upon, or
- the decision of the court of first instance is based on an incorrect legal assessment of the case.
A further appeal to the Supreme Court of the Slovak Republic is only available where the admissibility criteria set out in the Civil Dispute Procedure Code are satisfied.
21. What is an approximate timescale for the first/ second appeal?
The duration of appeal proceedings in patent matters is not fixed and depends on the specifics of each case, including its complexity, the conduct of the parties, and the workload of the adjudicating judge. As a general indication, a decision is usually issued within approximately 12 to 18 months.
The duration of proceedings before the Supreme Court of the Slovak Republic likewise depends on the individual circumstances of each case. In practice, a decision is typically delivered within a period of approximately up to 20 months.
22. Is the first instance decision suspended while an appeal is pending?
Yes. The decision issued at first instance does not become final or enforceable until the appeal process has been concluded.
V. Costs
23. What would be the estimated legal costs of patent litigation proceedings for a first instance decision?
The costs associated with patent litigation in Slovakia depend on the specific circumstances and complexity of each case. There is no standard or officially published estimate of typical legal expenses, as lawyers’ fees are usually determined by individual agreements with clients. As a result, total costs can differ widely, particularly in matters that are complex or involve significant technical detail.
24. What would be the estimated legal costs of patent litigation proceedings for an appeal?
The expenses related to appeal stages in Slovak patent litigation depend on the particular circumstances and complexity of the matter.
There is no standard or officially published figure for typical legal fees, since attorneys usually set their remuneration based on individual agreements. Consequently, the overall expenditure can differ considerably, particularly in cases involving significant complexity or technical issues.
25. Are litigation costs recoverable? If so, is there a limitation?
Yes. In civil court proceedings, the successful party is entitled to recover its costs. However, reimbursement is capped under the applicable regulation on lawyers’ fees, and the final amount awarded is partly subject to the court’s discretion. In administrative proceedings before the ÚPV SR (e.g. patent cancellation proceedings), the successful applicant is entitled to reimbursement of the administrative fee paid and, where represented by an advocate or patent attorney, also to reimbursement of costs in the amount of EUR 300, as provided under the Patent Act.
VI. Alternative Dispute Resolution
26. What are the options for alternative dispute resolution in your jurisdiction? Are these commonly used?
Parties involved in a dispute may opt for alternative dispute resolution methods, such as mediation or arbitration, instead of pursuing court proceedings. Mediation is recognised under Slovak law and can be applied to disputes arising from civil or commercial relationships.
Arbitration is also an option where the parties have agreed in advance to resolve their dispute in this way. In practice, however, ADR mechanisms are not frequently used in patent infringement cases in Slovakia, unless the dispute stems from an existing commercial or contractual relationship between the patent owner and the alleged infringer.
Additionally, the WIPO Arbitration and Mediation Center collaborates with the Industrial Property Office of the Slovak Republic to support and encourage the use of ADR in industrial property disputes within Slovakia.
27. Does the court require that parties consider these options at any stage in proceedings?
Throughout the proceedings, the court may prompt the parties to pursue an amicable resolution. Slovak procedural rules require the court, where suitable, to encourage settlement or suggest that the parties consider mediation. However, mediation is entirely voluntary, and the court cannot oblige the parties to participate. If no agreement is reached or mediation is declined, the case continues before the court.
VII. Remedies
28. What remedies are available for patent infringement? Does your jurisdiction provide for automatic injunctions in case of patent infringement?
The patent holder, or another person authorised under Slovak law, may seek several forms of relief, including but not limited to:
- an order to cease or prevent ongoing or imminent infringement;
- measures aimed at remedying the effects of the infringement;
- damages, including compensation for lost profits;
- disgorgement of any unjust enrichment gained through the infringement; and
- redress for non-pecuniary harm, which may include financial compensation.
In Slovakia, injunctions in patent infringement cases are not granted automatically. A request for an order prohibiting actual or threatened infringement must be made by the patent owner or another authorised party and is subject to a decision by the court.
29. On what basis are damages calculated? If damages are based on a reasonable royalty, how is this rate usually calculated?
Damages cover both the actual loss incurred by the claimant and any profit that would have been earned in the absence of the infringement.
Actual loss refers to the direct harm suffered by the patent owner, while lost profit reflects the revenue the owner could reasonably have expected if the infringement had not taken place. In addition, the patent owner may seek disgorgement of any unjust enrichment obtained by the infringer.
The amount of damages must generally be proven by the claimant and may be calculated on the basis of economic or expert evidence.
30. Does the court order an enquiry into damages (separate proceedings to determine the level of damages payable)?
Slovak courts do not conduct a separate assessment or inquiry into damages; it is the claimant who must prove the extent of its loss.
31. Is it possible to obtain additional remedies if the infringement was deliberate?
No. Slovak law instead recognises certain mitigations where the infringing party was unaware, and could not reasonably have been expected to be aware, of the infringement.
32. Can the court order a party to recall infringing products? If so, is there a limitation in time?
Yes. A court may order the infringer to withdraw the infringing goods from the market. While no specific time limit applies to such an order, it is effectively restricted by the duration of the patent’s protection.
VIII. Injunctions
33. Is it possible to obtain a preliminary injunction in your jurisdiction? If so, what are the requirements?
- Yes, a preliminary injunction may be granted. The court can issue such an order where:
- there is a concern that enforcement of a future judgment could be at risk.
A preliminary injunction is only available upon a duly reasoned application. In this application, the claimant must set out the key facts supporting the need for interim relief or the risk to enforcement, and must plausibly demonstrate both the existence and duration of the right to be protected.
The application must clearly indicate the specific interim measure sought and is, as a rule, subject to a court fee.
34. Is it possible to obtain a without notice injunction?
Yes. Interim injunctions can be issued on an ex parte basis, meaning the court may rule on the request without notifying the opposing party or inviting them to submit observations.
35. How quickly can preliminary injunctions be obtained?
The court is required to rule on an application for a preliminary injunction within 30 days from the date on which a compliant request is submitted.
36. Is it possible to appeal against a preliminary injunction and if so does this suspend the effect of the injunction?
Yes. A party may challenge an order granting a preliminary injunction by filing an appeal. However, such an appeal does not suspend the operation or effects of the injunction once it has been issued. Appeals are limited to arguing that the legal conditions required for granting the injunction were not fulfilled.
In addition, the defendant is entitled to apply for the injunction to be revoked if the circumstances underlying its issuance have changed and the measure is no longer justified.
37. If a party is awarded a preliminary injunction are they liable to provide security?
Under the Patent Act, in an order granting an urgent measure, the court may - even without a motion from any party - impose on the applicant a duty to deposit monetary security in an appropriate amount, or condition the enforceability of the urgent measure on the deposit of such security. The court determines both the amount of the security and the timeframe within which it must be deposited. Additionally, in the field of intellectual property, however, the claimant may propose that the alleged infringer be permitted to deposit security with the court in lieu of ceasing the contested activity. This security is intended to cover any damage or harm arising from the actual or threatened infringement of the intellectual property right. The court determines both the amount of the security and the timeframe within which it must be paid.
38. Are further proceedings on the merits required in order for the court to grant a final injunction?
Where a preliminary injunction is granted before proceedings on the merits have been commenced, the court may require the claimant to initiate the main action within a time limit it sets. If the claimant does not comply with this requirement, the preliminary injunction may be lifted.
39. Is a cross-border injunction available and in what circumstances?
Cross-border preliminary injunctions are, in principle, available, subject to the relevant rules governing jurisdiction, recognition, and enforcement. Within the European Union, these matters are primarily regulated by the Brussels I bis Regulation. As a result, an interim injunction issued by a Slovak court can be recognised and enforced in other EU Member States, and conversely, injunctions granted by courts in other Member States may be recognised and enforced in Slovakia.
For countries outside the EU, the availability and enforceability of such cross-border measures depend on the applicable international agreements or, in their absence, on Slovak private international law.
40. Is an Anti-Suit-Injunction (ASI) available and in what circumstances?
No. Anti-suit injunctions are not specifically provided for under Slovak law.