PB Development v Intact: Scottish court provides welcome guidance on Section 11 of the Insurance Act 2015
Please confirm you are human to start the audio.
In the recent decision in the case of PB Development Company Limited v Intact Insurance UK Limited [2026] CSOH 110, the Scottish Courts have provided timely guidance on the interpretation of Section 11 of the Insurance Act 2015 (the “2015 Act”).
Background
In September 2024, significant fire damage was caused to a restaurant in Aberdeen owned by PB Development (“PB”). PB made a claim under its insurance policy, which its insurers declined for breach of a condition precedent. The condition required that heat sources used in cooking were not left unattended. PB challenged the insurers’ declinature of its claim.
Section 11 of the 2015 Act
PB was found to be in breach of the condition precedent. However, PB argued that Section 11 of the 2015 Act prevented the insurer from relying on this breach to decline the claim on the basis that the breach of the condition did not change the risk profile of the loss.
Section 11 of the 2015 Act states:
- This section applies to a term (express or implied) of a contract of insurance, other than a term defining the risk as a whole, if compliance with it would tend to reduce the risk of one or more of the following—
(a) loss of a particular kind,
(b) loss at a particular location,
(c) loss at a particular time. - If a loss occurs, and the term has not been complied with, the insurer may not rely on the non-compliance to exclude, limit or discharge its liability under the contract for the loss if the insured satisfies subsection (3).
- The insured satisfies this subsection if it shows that the non-compliance with the term could not have increased the risk of the loss which actually occurred in the circumstances in which it occurred.
The Court noted that there is limited authority available on the interpretation and application of Section 11.
What limited authority there is suggests that the relevant test is whether breach of the term more generally was capable of increasing the risk of the loss, rather than a narrower test focused only on the particular nature of the particular breach in question.
The Court also considered the Explanatory Notes from the 2015 Act, reaching the view that Section 11 does not require an actual causal connection between the breach and the loss. Instead, the burden sits with an insured to show that its non-compliance could not increase the risk of the loss which actually occurred in the circumstances in which it occurred.
PB argued that, even if the cooking equipment had been attended, and so the condition precedent fulfilled, the risk of the fire starting and spreading in the way it did would not have been lower as operatives would not have identified the signs of a fire risk in time to prevent the fire occurring. The Court disagreed, finding that the condition precedent was aimed at mitigating both the risk which materialised (fire) and the mechanism by which it did so (spread of heat/flame from a cooking source). PB had therefore not shown on the balance of probabilities that Section 11 applied.
Takeaway
The introduction of Section 11 in the 2015 Act represented a significant change to the law. Despite the time that has passed since its introduction, there has been limited authority from the Courts on how the provision should be interpreted and applied. This decision provides timely and welcome guidance on the key considerations of the links between causation, mechanism of loss and the terms of the policy. It also provides support for a relatively broad, and insurer-friendly, interpretation of Section 11.
Prepared with input from Adam Forbes, trainee solicitor.