Denigrating but true? The High Court on the Scope of Non-Denigration Undertakings in Lord Ranger v Joshi
Please confirm you are human to start the audio.
On 25 September 2026, the High Court handed down its judgment in Lord Ranger v Joshi [2026] EWHC 2451 (KB). Richard Spearman KC, sitting as a Deputy Judge of the King’s Bench Division, ruled that “denigrate” means to “blacken, belittle, disparage the character or reputation of, defame”. Importantly, the meaning of denigration is broader than the meaning of defamation, and a statement can denigrate someone even if it is true. For parties entering into contracts, the decision is a clear warning that a non-denigration undertaking may be broad in scope.
Background
Lord Ranger, a Conservative Member of the House of Lords (the “Claimant”), and Poonam Joshi, a journalist (the “Defendant”), became involved in an acrimonious dispute over social media posts. The dispute led the Defendant to file complaints with the House of Lords Commissioner for Standards and the Headquarters of the Conservative Party. In response, the Claimant brought proceedings against the Defendant on 18 November 2022, alleging harassment and libel.
The parties engaged in mediation and the claim was settled on 31 May 2023. One of the terms of settlement was that “The Defendant and Claimant will not denigrate each other and/or pursue a course of conduct that amounts to harassment of the other” (the non-denigration undertaking, or “NDU”).
Between 13 June 2023 to 26 February 2026, the Defendant published nine posts on her social media pages. All but one linked to press reports containing details of the Claimant’s alleged bullying and harassment of her. In May 2026, the Claimant applied to lift the stay and enforce the NDU in relation to the Defendants’ publications.
The Defendant argued that the publications did not breach the NDU and that denigration must involve “unfairness or unreasonableness or inaccuracy”.
The Scope of the Non-Denigration Undertaking
The principal issue before the Court was the meaning of the Defendant’s undertaking not to “denigrate” the Claimant.
The Court rejected the Defendant’s argument that denigration must involve some element of “unfairness or unreasonableness or inaccuracy” and held that “denigrate” is to be given its ordinary meaning, to “blacken, belittle, disparage the character or reputation of, defame”.
The Court found support for the Claimant’s reliance upon the interpretation in RSM International Ltd v Harrison [2015] EWHC 2252 (QB) and Pertemps Medical Group Ltd v Ladak [2020] EWHC 163 (QB). Those decisions established that contractual restrictions on disparaging, derogatory or adverse statements are not confined to false statements. The Court considered those decisions consistent with the proposition that a statement may be denigratory even if it is true.
The Defendant argued that, had the parties intended to impose a broad restriction on criticism, they could have agreed an express non-disparagement clause and that a non-denigration clause should therefore be construed more narrowly. The Court rejected that submission. Noting that the ordinary meaning of “denigrate” includes “disparage”, the Court held that it was wrong to assume that a non-denigration clause is narrower or less effective than a non-disparagement clause. The decision therefore suggests that, despite the difference in terminology, a non-denigration undertaking may in practice impose restrictions comparable to those typically associated with non-disparagement clauses.
The Court also rejected the Defendant’s submission that, in the context of the parties’ dispute, denigration should be construed as a form of bullying or harassment. In doing so, it emphasised that the NDU prohibited denigration and harassment separately, and that the use of the words “and/or” demonstrated that the parties intended those concepts to be distinct.
As a result, the Court concluded that the Defendant’s publications breached the NDU. The Court therefore lifted the stay and granted injunctive relief, although on more limited terms than those sought by the Claimant. In particular, the Court did not treat the Defendant’s description of the Conservative Party’s decision to readmit the Claimant as “appalling and totally unethical” as denigratory, holding that the criticism was directed at the Conservative Party rather than the Claimant himself.
Comment
Non-denigration undertakings may have significant practical consequences and can extend to true, fair or accurate statements. Parties entering into contracts, including settlement agreements, should therefore carefully consider the scope of any undertaking regarding future statements.