Cool it: landlord’s new HVAC claim gets a frosty reception
Please confirm you are human to start the audio.
Authors
Ageing plant is often one of the biggest items in a dilapidations claim at lease end. In Craigard (Dartford) Ltd v Westbury Homes (Holdings) Ltd [2026] EWHC 2453 (TCC), the landlord spent over £566k on a brand-new HVAC system and sought to recover it from its former tenant. The High Court instead valued the HVAC element at the cost of repairing the old system: just under £164k.
There is no new law here, but the case is a clear reminder that if worn-out plant can realistically be repaired, the tenant only pays for repair. A tenant can meet its repair obligations in the cheapest reasonable way, and it is for the landlord to prove that replacement was genuinely needed.
The landlord’s plans to refurbish did not reduce the repair costs it could claim, but it could not recover rent lost during the works, because it would have lost that rent anyway.
What happened
The tenant’s 20-year lease of a Dartford office building required it to keep the building, including the HVAC system, in good repair. The original system used a refrigerant that can no longer legally be used and had been failing for years, yet the tenant’s agent hoped it would “appear functional” at lease end. The landlord, which bought the building in 2021, had told investors and occupiers it would install a new, energy-efficient system, and did so as part of a refurbishment costing over £1.6m.
What the court decided
HHJ Keyser KC found that the tenant’s failure to maintain the system was “calculated” and that its last-minute works merely kept it running. Even so, the landlord had not proved that a new system was needed.
Where a reasonable specialist could recommend either repair or replacement, damages are assessed on the (cheaper) repair basis. Tellingly, the landlord’s own engineers’ report had itemised and priced repairs to the old system, which showed that repair was a realistic option. The landlord’s case was also weakened because its contractor was only ever asked how to replace the system, not whether it could be repaired.
The court therefore valued the HVAC element at a repair cost of just under £164k (mainly a replacement chiller plus cleaning and minor works), against the £566k the landlord actually spent. Overall, the landlord recovered around £648k of its £1.6m claim.
The tenant also argued it should pay nothing for repairs because the landlord would have ripped out a repaired system anyway. The court rejected this as “contrary to well established law”: a landlord can recover repair costs whatever its plans, subject to the statutory cap on damages. However, lost rent and the cost of relocating occupiers were not recoverable, as they would have been incurred during the refurbishment anyway. Surveyors’ and legal fees were recoverable under the lease.
Why it matters
HVAC is often one of the most expensive items at when it forms part of a dilapidations claim at lease end, and landlords frequently want to use the moment to upgrade for ESG and marketing reasons. This case is a useful reminder that the gap between what a landlord wants and what a tenant must pay can be very large. Landlords should not assume a dilapidations claim will fund a new system; tenants with old plant should get a credible, priced repair option on the table.
Key takeaways
- Repair beats replace: if old plant can realistically be repaired, the tenant pays for repair only. Landlords must prove replacement was necessary.
- Get the right evidence: landlords claiming for replacement need contemporaneous test results and specialist advice that genuinely considered repair.
- Upgrade plans cut both ways: they do not reduce repair costs, but rent lost during works the landlord would have done anyway is not recoverable.
- The statutory cap: damages cannot exceed the drop in the property’s value; here the court assumed a typical buyer would be happy with a repaired, working system.
- Watch what you write: emails, investor updates and tenant correspondence were decisive evidence on both sides.
This article was co-written by Talitha Marsh.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice.