Sorting rules (Triman and Info-Tri)
As of 1 January 2022, the Circular Economy Law has imposed that products intended for households and covered by an EPR scheme in France, excluding household glass packaging for beverages, must be marked with the Triman logo and an information on how to sort or bring in waste from the product. Such information is known as ‘Info-Tri’.
The Info-Tri is established by the eco-organizations in charge of the relevant EPR scheme depending on the product category. It is applied in a differentiated manner to each component of the product or the waste coming from the product if they are subject to different sorting methods.
Please note that on 15 February 2023, the EU Commission opened an infringement procedure by sending a letter of formal notice to France for failure to address its labelling requirements concerning waste sorting instructions with the principle of free movement of goods.
The EU Commission indicated that:
- The imposition of national-specific labelling requirements risks undermining the principle of free movement of goods and can lead to counterproductive environmental effects. Such measures can also lead to increased material needs for additional labelling and additional waste produced due to larger than necessary sizes of the packaging;
- The French authorities do not seem to have conducted a sufficient analysis of the proportionality of their policy choice as other suitable options, less restrictive of trade between Member States, are available. France is also considered in breach of the notification obligations under the Single Market Transparency Directive (Directive (EU) 2015/1535) to the extent that the law was not notified to the Commission at a draft stage, prior to adoption.
This infringement procedure does not suspend the application of the current French rules.
As things stand, it seems rather likely that France will adapt the rules on the Triman marking in the short/medium term. In particular, the obligation to affix the Triman logo and Info-Tri directly on household packaging (which seems to be the main issue as regards the principle of free movement of goods) might be removed or mitigated. However, France could also try to resist on this issue for political reasons.
Update on the Green Dot
The penalty on the eco-contribution that France has sought to impose on users of the Green Dot, accused of being a source of confusion for consumers as to the rules of sorting, is still suspended, the French Council of State being called upon to rule on its legality in light of EU law.
For further context, the Circular Economy law provided for the application of a penalty on producers using potentially confusing markings or signage for consumers that will at least double their eco-contribution paid to the relevant eco-organization.
In the disputed Order of November 30th, 2020, the French Minister for the Ecological Transition designated as potentially confusing markings and signage, graphic figures representing two or more arrows rolled up and inscribed in a circle. The Order aims unequivocally at the Green Dot.
On March 15th, 2021, the Conseil d’Etat, referred by several major professional associations and by the holder and licensor of the Green Dot trademark in the European Union, suspended the application of the disputed Order. It notably highlighted that the penalization of the Green Dot would force producers to design new packaging or adapt their distribution channels within a very short timeframe or risk being financially penalized.
It also considered that the Minister of Ecological Transition did not provide any proof that the disappearance of the Green Dot signage would be likely to change sorting habits on its own. A decision on the merits is still pending.
Environmental qualities and characteristics
As of 1 January 2022, there is an obligation to inform consumers about the environmental qualities and characteristics of waste-generating products (incorporation of recycled material, use of renewable resources, durability, compostability, repairability, possibilities for reuse, recyclability and presence of dangerous substances, precious metals or rare earths).
Decree n° 2022-748 on consumer information on the environmental qualities and characteristics of waste generating products defines the implementing modalities of such information obligation. The information, which concerns products subject to EPR schemes under specific criteria, must be given as of 1 January, 2023, 2024 or 2025, depending on the annual turnover declared for the products concerned (> €10M) and the number of units of products concerned placed on the French market (> 10,000 units).
This information shall be made available in a dematerialized format, accessible free of charge at the time of purchase and reusable so as to allow aggregation. To this end, for each product concerned, the information is available on a dedicated website or web page containing a sheet entitled "product sheet relating to environmental qualities and characteristics".
France also introduced compulsory warnings (e.g. "do not discard in the wild" for plastic products and packaging that can be composted by domestic or industrial composting) and prohibited claims (“compostable” for plastic products and packaging whose compostability can only be obtained in an industrial unit; "biodegradable" or "environmentally friendly" or any similar claim on any products or packaging) for products and packaging made of plastic.
As of 1 January 2022, for any product presented as "recycled", the percentage of recycled material actually incorporated has to be indicated.
Repairability and durability ratings
The Repairability Index is presented in the form of an indication "repairability index" with a pictogram indicating a score out of ten associated with a color code from red to dark green. It is based on five categories of criteria. Specific administrative orders have been taken to detail those criteria for certain categories of products. Nine categories of EEE are currently concerned: televisions; smartphones; laptops; washing machines with windows, top-of-the-line washing machines, lawnmowers, dishwashers, vacuum cleaners, and high-pressure cleaners.
The Index is placed on the product, on its packaging or near its price, both in stores and on online sales sites.
Although the obligation on producers and distributors of EEE to communicate the Repairability Index of their EEE, free of charge, entered into force on 1 January 2021, effective enforcement only started as of January 2022.
From 1 January 2024, a product durability rating (covering the reliability and robustness of the product) will either supplement or replace the repairability rating.
Ban on bisphenol A (BPA) in Food packaging
Importing and placing on the market of packaging, containers or utensils containing BPA and intended to come into direct contact with food were suspended in December 2012.
In addition, the National Food Agency (ANSES) proposes identifying bisphenol B as a substance of very high concern under the REACH Regulation (like BPA) in order to prevent the industrial usage of this chemical on the European continent as a replacement for bisphenol A, and to require importers of consumer goods to declare its presence in concentrations exceeding a threshold of 0.1%.
Obligation information on endocrine disruptors
Please also note that as of January 1, 2022, specific information obligations are also provided for regarding endocrine disruptors.
Decree n° 2021-1110 of 23 August 2021 notably provides that any person who places on the market products containing substances that, according to ANSES, have endocrine disrupting properties, shall publish the list of these products and the substances contained in each of them.
This information is made available in a dematerialized format, accessible free of charge and reusable in order to allow aggregation. If the product concerned is also the subject of an obligation of information of the consumers under the qualities and environmental characteristics, this information is made available on the same dematerialised sheet.
This chapter was last updated on December 2023 and does not reflect any subsequent developments in the law.
Social Media cookies collect information about you sharing information from our website via social media tools, or analytics to understand your browsing between social media tools or our Social Media campaigns and our own websites. We do this to optimise the mix of channels to provide you with our content. Details concerning the tools in use are in our privacy policy.