Authors
Background
Both focus on investing in long-term and illiquid assets in areas such as venture capital, private equity, private debt, real estate and infrastructure. These long-term assets are not typically traded on public markets and so are not subject to continual daily opportunities to buy and sell them. Investment usually requires a long-term commitment. These types of funds need to be authorised by their regulator and are subject to investment restriction rules set out in their respective regulatory framework.
Reasons for Change
ELTIFs failed to meet their original intended success due to restrictive features and not having the same international brand recognition as UCITS. However, they are starting to become more popular within the EEA. This is in part due to the reforms of the ELTIF regulation (as discussed further below) which is intended to increase flexibility. Another factor in increased interest in these funds is because the reforms make it easier for retail investors to invest in ELTIFs by removing some barriers to entry. As private funds managers are increasingly looking to access retail capital, especially high net worth investors, we can expect to see more of these funds.
The table below shows a breakdown of where ELTIFs are currently domiciled:
In the UK market we can see a similar trend. In July 2023, the Government laid legislation to repeal the European Long-Term Investment Fund (ELTIF) Regulation, which will come into force from 1 January 2024. This will not be replaced, because no ELTIFs have been established in the UK, and the new UK LTAF regime and recent FCA reforms enabling wider distribution provide an alternative fund structure better suited to the needs of the UK market. Since the launch of the first LTAF earlier this year, there has been an uptick in interest for the LTAF and this may grow with the FCAs recent amendments to the distribution of LTAF units.
Key Features Comparison
Below we set out some comparisons of the key features of these funds. It should be noted that most of the ELTIF features described below will only start applying as from 10 January 2024 which is the date of application of the new Regulation (EU) 2023/606 (ELTIF Amending Regulation) 1 , which amends the current ELTIF framework. This briefing does not relate to the tax treatment of ELTIFs or LTAFs.
| Forms | ||
|---|---|---|
| Feature | ELTIF | LTAF |
| Year of introduction | 2015 | 2021 |
| Jurisdiction | Domiciled and authorised in its home member EEA state. | United Kingdom. |
| What is it? | A type of EU domiciled regulated alternative investment fund (AIF) introduced in the European Union to encourage investment into companies and projects which need long-term capital and increase the number of long-term investment opportunities available to institutional and private investors across Europe. ELTIF is a label on top of regular national product laws – for instance, in Luxembourg:
In principle, ELTIFs are closed-ended. Early redemptions during the life of the ELTIF under specific conditions to be developed in draft regulatory technical standards (RTS) by the ESMA (e.g., minimum holding period, detailed redemption policy, matching mechanism). | Similar to the ELTIF, a UK category of authorised fund designed to invest efficiently in long-term assets. Can take the following forms:
|
| Eligible investors | Institutional investors and retail investors with no minimum financial portfolio requirement and no minimum investment amount. | UK Professional investors UK DC pension schemes. SIPPs High net worth and other retail investors can also invest in the LTAF. |
| Can it be a Master-feeder structure? | Yes, as long as the master remains an ELTIF. | Yes (subject to operating conditions e.g COLL 15.9 Operational requirements for feeder LTAFs). |
| Regulation | ||
|---|---|---|
| Feature | ELTIF | LTAF |
| Regulation | Regulation (EU) 2015/760 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 29 April 2015 on European long-term investment funds. 2 The ELTIF Amending Regulation shall start applying as from 10 January 2024, with a five- year transitional period for pre-existing ELTIFs that are still raising capital and an opt- in regime, for those ELTIF managers who want to opt into the revised rules, by notifying their member state NCA. | The FCA rules set out in COLL. Authorised fund managers (AFMs) will also need to comply with rules in other sourcebooks forming part of the FCA rules including PRIN, FUND, COBS and SYSC. |
| Regulatory authority | An EEA Regulatory Authority (e.g, the Luxembourg Commission de Surveillance du Secteur Financier (CSSF)). | The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). |
| Marketing | ELTIFs can avail of an EEA marketing passport, for marketing to both retail and professional investors. | Cannot be sold into EEA states unless their private placement regime permits this. LTAFs can be marketed within the UK subject to the FCA marketing rules. |
| Do you need to have the fund itself approved by the regulator? | Yes. Must apply for authorisation to its home state regulator, submitting as part of its application (among other things) its rules of incorporation, the identity of its proposed manager and depositary and a description of the information to be made available to investors. | Yes. The FCA is required by law to authorise or reject an authorisation application, for an authorised fund other than a UCITS, within 6 months. However, the application can be quicker. |
| Investment | ||
|---|---|---|
| Feature | ELTIF | LTAF |
| What can it invest in? | At least 55% 3 of its of its capital in eligible investment assets:
| At least 50% of its asset value in long- term, illiquid assets. This could include (directly or indirectly):
The principle of prudent spread of risk applies. |
| Loans and Debt | Yes (subject to limits and restrictions):
| Yes (subject to limits and restrictions) 4 |
| Can it invest in other funds? | Yes, fund-of-funds strategy is allowed with a maximum limit of 100%. | Yes, fund of funds strategy is allowed (subject to due diligence and the other fund(s) meeting certain conditions). |
| Investment Restrictions | ||
|---|---|---|
| Feature | ELTIF | LTAF |
| Restrictions | Diversification requirements: An ELTIF shall invest no more than:
Aggregate risk exposure to STS is limited to 20% of the ELTIF’s capital. Concentration limits: An ELTIF may acquire no more than 30 % of the units or shares of a single ELTIF, EuVECA, EuSEF, UCITS or of an EU AIF managed by an EU AIFM. Both diversification requirements and concentration limits shall not apply where ELTIFs are marketed solely to professional investors. | The FCA expects the investment strategy of a long-term asset fund to be to invest at least 50% of the value of the scheme property in unlisted securities and other long-term assets. As noted above, the over-arching diversification requirement is that there is a “prudent spread of risk”. Subject to that, there are comparatively few express spread/concentration requirements. |
| Derivatives | Yes (subject to certain conditions). Aggregate risk exposure to a counterparty from OTC derivative transactions, repurchase agreements, or reverse repurchase agreements limited to 10% of ELTIF’s capital. A financial derivative instrument shall only be used for hedging risks arising from exposures to eligible investment assets and the use of the financial derivative instruments aimed to provide a return for the ELTIF shall not be deemed to serve the purpose of hedging the risks. ESMA shall develop draft regulatory technical standards (RTS) to determine the criteria for establishing the circumstances in which the use of financial derivative instruments solely serves hedging purpose. | Yes (subject to certain conditions). The total exposure relating to derivatives held in a LTAF may not exceed the net value of the scheme property. Maximum exposure must be covered globally. |
| Fund Liquidity | ||
|---|---|---|
| Feature | ELTIF | LTAF |
| Redemptions and liquidity tools | While these funds are in principle closed- ended, the ELTIF Amending Regulation introduces the possibility for de facto open- ended ELTIFs, allowing redemption rights for ELTIF investors during the lifetime of the ELTIF under specific requirements. 5 The requirements include appropriate redemption policies and liquidity management tools are compatible with the relevant ELTIF’s long-term investment strategy. A matching mechanism should be put in place with full or partial matching of transfer requests of units or shares of the ELTIF by exiting investors with transfer requests by potential investors. | The fund is open-ended but it needs to have notice periods on redemptions (including minimum redemption notice period of 90 days). The fund will also typically have liquidity tools such as
Any liquidity management tools must be clearly disclosed in the prospectus (including worked examples of what they mean for investors in practice). |
| Management and Governance | ||
|---|---|---|
| Feature | ELTIF | LTAF |
| Who can manage it? | An EEA authorised AIFM | A full-scope UK AIFM with permission to manage an authorised AIF |
| Depositary | Yes. The AIFMD rules on depositary apply. | Yes. The UK AIFMD rules on depositary apply (as modified by COLL 15). See COLL 15.7.6 for the duties of the depositary. |
| Valuation | Most of the assets within are likely to be illiquid and many will not have regular market prices. So, the regulations set out rules to ensure fair and accurate valuation | Must appoint an external valuer, unless the UK AIFM can demonstrate that it has the competence and experience to value assets of the type in which the LTAF invests. If the UK AIFM ceases to have this capacity it will have to appoint an external valuer. 6 |
| Reporting | At least annually. There are requirements as to what needs to be in the annual report of the ELTIF. | A report in respect of each annual accounting period, half-yearly accounting period and quarterly reporting period. The depositary must make an annual report to unitholders which must be included in the annual report. |
| Leverage and Debt | ||
|---|---|---|
| Feature | ELTIF | LTAF |
| Borrowing | An ELTIF may borrow cash if it represents:
| Borrowing is capped at 30% of the NAV of the scheme; as such this may constrain investment in infrastructure and other similar asset classes. |
| Protections | ||
|---|---|---|
| Feature | ELTIF | LTAF |
| Retail investors | ELTIF managers are still required to conduct suitability assessments of retail investors and take certain additional steps in order to meet the needs of retail investors. For example, managers must provide written alerts when marketing an ELTIF with a term of more than 10 years. However, the burden of marketing to retail investors and admitting them into an ELTIF has been reduced under the ELTIF Amending Regulation:
| Units in the LTAF are, with effect from 3 July 2023, now categorised as restricted mass market investments and may be marketed to retail investors, subject to providing requisite risk warnings on liquidity. Where there are retail investors. Additional retail protection measures apply. |
The content in this document is for general purposes and guidance only. It does not constitute legal or professional advice and should not be relied on or treated as a substitute for specific advice relevant to particular circumstances. For legal advice, please contact your main contact partner at the relevant CMS member firm.