Home / Publications / CMS Green Globe / News in Sustainability Claims / Germany: Court decides on Advertising of Climate Neutrality...
  1. Global Trends
  2. News in Sustainability Claims
    1. France: Extended Producer Responsibility
    2. Germany: New court decision: Advertising climate neutrality
    3. UK: Investigations by CMA into the fashion sector
    4. Switzerland: Initiative for recycling plastic
    5. Austria: “Greenwashing check” – Recycling
    6. France: Sorting rules (Triman and Info-Tri): hot topic
    7. UK ad regulator issues harsh ruling on “misleading” environmental advertising
    8. The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia: Carbon credit market in The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
    9. Switzerland: Climate disclosures for Swiss large companies in force as of 1 January 2024
    10. Italy: Sustainability in the fashion industry
    11. Switzerland: Swiss Federal Council takes action against greenwashing in the financial sector
    12. France: Update on the Green Dot
    13. UK: CMA announces review into the FMCG sector
    14. EU Commission makes another push to prevent greenwashing
    15. France: Single-use tableware in on-site restaurants is no longer allowed
    16. Germany and the EU: New study on competition and sustainability in Germany and the EU
    17. France: Carbon neutrality claims
    18. France: Update on the Triman
    19. France: Update of the Practical Guide to Environmental Claims
    20. Switzerland: The Swiss Bankers Association (SBA) has included a new section on ESG risks
    21. Netherlands: Dutch regulator updates Guidelines on sustainability claims
    22. UK: Transparency in “green” claims: UK Advertising Regulator updates guidance on misleading environmental claims
    23. France: Annulment of the Green Dot penalty – CMS Francis Lefebvre, legal advisor of the claimants
    24. Germany: Court decides on Advertising of Climate Neutrality in two Appeal Proceedings
    25. Switzerland: Advertising of carbon neutrality at sports events
    26. Germany: German Court decides on advertising of climate neutrality based on a CO₂ compensation by a forest conservation project
    27. UK: CMA launches greenwashing investigation into boiler manufacturer
    28. EU: Stricter regulations to combat greenwashing and to empower consumers on the horizon
    29. Belgium: New decision about an advertisement for an SUV
    30. UK: ASA bans Toyota advertisement for promoting environmentally irresponsible behaviour
    31. Germany: New decision concerning CO2 positive and climate neutral production advertisement
    32. Mexico: New amendments to the Environmental Law for the Protection of the Land
  3. Common Trends for EU
  4. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in Austria
  5. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in Belgium
  6. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in Brazil
  7. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in Bulgaria
  8. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in China
  9. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in Chile
  10. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in Colombia
  11. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in Croatia
  12. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in the Czech Republic
  13. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in Germany
  14. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in France
  15. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in Hungary
  16. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in Italy
  17. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in Mexico
  18. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in Morocco
    1. Maroc - Déclarations de durabilité et écoblanchiment
  19. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in the Netherlands
  20. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in Norway
  21. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in Poland
  22. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in Portugal
  23. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in Romania
  24. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in Saudi Arabia
  25. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in Singapore
  26. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in Slovakia
  27. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in Slovenia
  28. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in Spain
  29. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in Sweden
  30. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in Switzerland
  31. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in Turkiye
  32. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in the UAE
  33. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in Ukraine
  34. Sustainability claims and greenwashing in the United Kingdom

German Court decides on Advertising of Climate Neutrality in two Appeal Proceedings

July 2023

On 6 July 2023, the Higher Regional Court Düsseldorf (OLG Düsseldorf) ruled in two cases – one case concerning a fruit gum manufacturer and the other a jam manufacturer – that advertising “climate neutrality” is not per se misleading advertising.

It confirmed the previous decision by the OLG Schleswig (see our news of June 2022) that the average consumer understands climate neutrality in the sense of a balance of the CO2 emissions of a product and it is clear that this can be achieved by emission reducing as well as compensation measures. However, the advertiser has a certain duty to duly inform the consumer and the court ruled that the way in which climate neutrality is achieved constitutes essential information for the consumer to make an informed purchase decision. In the rulings the court emphasized the importance of climate protection for consumers and the considerable influence such claims can have on the purchase decision. The court ruled that the reference to further information on how the climate neutrality is achieved was missing with respect to the case of the jam manufacturer whereas a QR code/link to a website with further information was deemed sufficient in the case of the fruit gum manufacturer.

Both appeal decisions are not legally binding as the court allowed an appeal to the Federal Supreme Court (BGH) due to the fundamental importance of the issues in dispute.

For more information on sustainability claims and greenwashing in Germany please see here.

Key contact

Dr. Philine-Luise Pulst, LL.M. (University of Cape Town)
Counsel
Rechtsanwältin
Hamburg
T +49 40 37630 306